Saturday February 12, 2011
SINGAPORE: Singapore state investment firm Temasek Holdings yesterday it had paid a 15 billion rupiah (US$1.7mil) fine imposed for breaching anti-competition laws in Indonesia's telecoms sector.
The commission ruled in November 2007 that Temasek was guilty of anti-competitive behaviour through its stakes in Indonesia's two biggest domestic mobile phone operators.
Temasek said it made the payment in compliance with an Indonesian Supreme Court ruling that upheld the commission's decision, but maintained the company had “never been involved” in any irregularity.
Analysts said Temasek decided to pay the fine to avoid any repercussions non-payment would have had for further investment in Indonesia.
“I think that they clearly are looking to Indonesia as a potentially lucrative market for their investments,” said David Cohen, director of Asian economic forecasting at Action Economics.
He said it was easier for Temasek to pay the fine and “get on with things.” AFP
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/2/12/business/8049166&sec=business
Showing posts with label Industry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Industry. Show all posts
Monday, September 12, 2011
Thursday, August 18, 2011
Tuesday, May 17, 2011
Is There Room for HSBB and Mobile Broadband to Co-Exist?
Saturday May 7, 2011
WHILE competition among high-speed fixed and mobile broadband operators is getting increasingly fierce, industry players believe there is room for both to co-exist given the size of the market. Lending credence to this is the different user behaviour among consumers.
According to Frost & Sullivan, wireless broadband has been fast gaining popularity over fixed broadband with almost two million wireless broadband subscribers compared to 1.65 million fixed broadband subscribers in 2010.
In 2009, fixed broadband dominated over wireless broadband with 1.4 million subscribers to 0.9 million subscribers.
Still, fixed broadband will gain market share in 2011 and 2012 due to the introduction of high-speed broadband and wholesale deals by Maxis and Celcom. Governmental support for high-speed broadband will also help drive the fixed broadband market. The Malaysian fixed broadband market is expected to reach 2.2 million subscribers in 2015.
Here is what they have to say:
Datuk Seri Shazalli Ramly
Chief executive officer
Celcom Axiata Bhd
Each player will have its own clarity on how to position its company in the context of the nation's Internet penetration. We are very clear of wanting to be the top mobile broadband player. To allow mobile access to grow you need the mobile smartphones, you can't split the devices any more. The convergence is happening and we definitely want to be in that space.
We will find the ways and means to build a network that allows nomadic and mobile users to access our network and, by design, help to achieve the numbers (broadband penetration rate) that they want.
I feel there is a blurring codependency taking place at the moment not by design but by behaviour.
Mark Dioguardi
Executive vice-president,
network and technology Maxis Bhd
We are now moving into machineto- machine communication and the mass market is looking for reliable and consistent connection.
Since last year, we have been making steady investments to upgrade our systems to provide the widest 3G coverage, geographically and capacity to allow more people to access Maxis.
Good things are happening in Malaysia. If you put Singapore aside, Malaysia is quite aggressive in terms of the fibre-to-home broadband. There have been a lot of progress. It's an Utopian view.
Datuk Seri Zamzamzairani Mohd Isa
Group CEO Telekom Malaysia Bhd
We have to compete. And customer will have a choice. Each provider will serve the needs. There will be newer technologies that will provide competition. It will only benefit the customer. We will have to do our best to fight our corner in the retail side.
We are fixed on fibre but looking at the needs of our customer, we would like to complement it holistically. We are providing WiFi today. When we started last year, we have 2,000 hotspots and now we have 13,000. We will be rolling out WiFi hotspots in more locations that are suitable for customers that need the service.
That is in wireless form.
Michael Lai
Chief Executive Officer
Packet One Networks (PI)
We started from zero and we have diligently invested a lot of money to build our network. Our network is built for data and broadband and we have covered 45% of populated areas in the country. The demand for our services are growing and we are now looking to launch our huddles in one to two months time.
For the future, we are working on a co-existence strategy, taking advantage of our Wimax to test LTE (long term evolution). The migration to LTE for us will not be a costly affair since ZTE claims it would involve only a software upgrade. We started the 4G journey ahead of many others and we want to keep the lead.
Afzal Abdul Rahim
Chief Executive Officer
Time dotCom Bhd
We are focused and we intend to push the boundaries. Since February 2010, we have been providing the fastest Internet speed in Malaysia at 50Mbps and we will bring this service to 170,000 Malaysian homes in 2011.
We also hope to continue playing a major role in being the invisible infrastructure provider to Malaysia's leading operators in transporting their traffic and broadband services on our 100% nationwide fibre optic network.
As a small but nimble player, it is our responsibility to ensure that Malaysians get the internet experience they deserve.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/7/business/8617444&sec=business
WHILE competition among high-speed fixed and mobile broadband operators is getting increasingly fierce, industry players believe there is room for both to co-exist given the size of the market. Lending credence to this is the different user behaviour among consumers.
According to Frost & Sullivan, wireless broadband has been fast gaining popularity over fixed broadband with almost two million wireless broadband subscribers compared to 1.65 million fixed broadband subscribers in 2010.
In 2009, fixed broadband dominated over wireless broadband with 1.4 million subscribers to 0.9 million subscribers.
Still, fixed broadband will gain market share in 2011 and 2012 due to the introduction of high-speed broadband and wholesale deals by Maxis and Celcom. Governmental support for high-speed broadband will also help drive the fixed broadband market. The Malaysian fixed broadband market is expected to reach 2.2 million subscribers in 2015.
Here is what they have to say:
Datuk Seri Shazalli Ramly
Chief executive officer
Celcom Axiata Bhd
Each player will have its own clarity on how to position its company in the context of the nation's Internet penetration. We are very clear of wanting to be the top mobile broadband player. To allow mobile access to grow you need the mobile smartphones, you can't split the devices any more. The convergence is happening and we definitely want to be in that space.
We will find the ways and means to build a network that allows nomadic and mobile users to access our network and, by design, help to achieve the numbers (broadband penetration rate) that they want.
I feel there is a blurring codependency taking place at the moment not by design but by behaviour.
Mark Dioguardi
Executive vice-president,
network and technology Maxis Bhd
We are now moving into machineto- machine communication and the mass market is looking for reliable and consistent connection.
Since last year, we have been making steady investments to upgrade our systems to provide the widest 3G coverage, geographically and capacity to allow more people to access Maxis.
Good things are happening in Malaysia. If you put Singapore aside, Malaysia is quite aggressive in terms of the fibre-to-home broadband. There have been a lot of progress. It's an Utopian view.
Datuk Seri Zamzamzairani Mohd Isa
Group CEO Telekom Malaysia Bhd
We have to compete. And customer will have a choice. Each provider will serve the needs. There will be newer technologies that will provide competition. It will only benefit the customer. We will have to do our best to fight our corner in the retail side.
We are fixed on fibre but looking at the needs of our customer, we would like to complement it holistically. We are providing WiFi today. When we started last year, we have 2,000 hotspots and now we have 13,000. We will be rolling out WiFi hotspots in more locations that are suitable for customers that need the service.
That is in wireless form.
Michael Lai
Chief Executive Officer
Packet One Networks (PI)
We started from zero and we have diligently invested a lot of money to build our network. Our network is built for data and broadband and we have covered 45% of populated areas in the country. The demand for our services are growing and we are now looking to launch our huddles in one to two months time.
For the future, we are working on a co-existence strategy, taking advantage of our Wimax to test LTE (long term evolution). The migration to LTE for us will not be a costly affair since ZTE claims it would involve only a software upgrade. We started the 4G journey ahead of many others and we want to keep the lead.
Afzal Abdul Rahim
Chief Executive Officer
Time dotCom Bhd
We are focused and we intend to push the boundaries. Since February 2010, we have been providing the fastest Internet speed in Malaysia at 50Mbps and we will bring this service to 170,000 Malaysian homes in 2011.
We also hope to continue playing a major role in being the invisible infrastructure provider to Malaysia's leading operators in transporting their traffic and broadband services on our 100% nationwide fibre optic network.
As a small but nimble player, it is our responsibility to ensure that Malaysians get the internet experience they deserve.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/7/business/8617444&sec=business
Speed rules in broadband
Saturday May 7, 2011
By LEONG HUNG YEE
hungyee@thestar.com.my
AFTER a much publicised kick-off, high speed broadband (HSBB) access in various forms is starting to take shape in Malaysia. Of late, there has been a flurry of activity as service providers rush to provide fixed-line broadband by riding on Telekom Malaysia Bhd's (TM) infrastructure.
UK-based Informa Telecoms & Media senior analyst Tony Brown tells StarBizWeek that TM's UniFi service, which got off to a relatively slow start in terms of subscriber growth, is really starting to pick up and growth prospects look good.
“Now that Maxis Bhd is selling HSBB services and Celcom Axiata Bhd is also likely to start doing so by year-end, we are going to see a big shift of subscribers moving away from DSL (Digital Subscriber Line) services towards the HSBB network,” he says.
The RM11.3bil HSBB project, signed in September 2008, is a public-private partnership agreement between TM and the Government to develop next-generation HSBB infrastructure and services for the nation.
TM is forking out RM8.9bil while the Government is co-investing RM2.4bil on an incurred claims basis based on project milestones reached by TM.
By end-2012 in accordance with the completion of the first phase of the national HSBB project roll-out as agreed with the Government about 1.3 million premises will have access to the HSBB services.
According to the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), government plays a special role in many developing countries in creating demand for next-generation broadband services.
“Building up fixed broadband infrastructure typically involves large-scale investments over long-time horizons and the private sector benefits from more certain prospects in its attempts to finance and roll out such infrastructure.
The foresight to develop an ultra-fast broadband infrastructure is not only limited to Malaysia. Countries as diverse as Australia, Brazil, China and India have launched broadband initiatives respectively.
Elsewhere in the region, there are also a slew of activities happening with regard to HSBB. Some countries have already rolled out their HSBB while some are currently in the midst of developing the infrastructure.
“K-broadband”
Analysts say closing the broadband gap has become a priority for many governments.
South Korea has announced its plans to build a super broadband infrastructure with upload and download speeds of 1Gbps by 2013 through a fibre-optic cable. The project is reported to cost about US$24.5bil, and will largely be funded by the private sector.
The country, which prides itself as being one of the world's most wired countries, already has the best download speeds around the globe. “You will not fail to be impressed by the speed of the country's online connections,” says an analyst. The country is in fact in the process of developing an even faster broadband speed.
According to speedtest.net, South Korea's average download speed of 30.64Mbps currently ranks the first in the world. The results were obtained by analysing test data between March 30 and May 2. By comparison, Malaysia ranks 102 with an average download speed of 2.61Mbps.
Wired broadband, however, is just at the beginning in South Korea; the Korea Communications Commission (KCC) has plans to ramp up its wireless broadband to 10Mbps.
Indeed, it would be interesting to see how things shape up in South Korea once the fibre-optic infrastructure is rolled out.
“At the rate South Korea is going, it is quite possible that the nation will give us a glimpse of our own wired future,” he says. The Korean project, largely funded by the private sector, is key to growing the country's status as a middle-income nation after years of economic despair. Home-grown online gaming and entertainment have also boomed in South Korea as a result of its investment in broadband infrastructure.
Experience Down Under
Informa Telecoms & Media's Brown says the HSBB rollout in Malaysia is one of the most interesting “National Broadband Network” (NBN) type deployments thus far as it targets a very specific part of the nation; it only covers 20% of total homes with its 1.3 million homes passed target.
“However, this very specific targeting has enabled TM and the Government to bring the project in for just US$3.78bil which is way below what is being spent by the Australian government in its own NBN deployment,” he says.
The Australian government plans to invest as much as A$43bil over eight years to build a high-speed Internet network to connect 90% of the nation's homes and create jobs.
The Australian government has also created a new company, NBN Co Ltd, to build and operate the broadband network in urban, regional and rural areas. The government will own at least 51% of a company that will make initial investments of A$4.7bil to build and operate the network.
NBN Co says the capital expenditure for the project is estimated at A$35.9bil, of which the Australian government's contribution will be A$27.5bil in equity in the project.
The NBN will involve the laying of fibre-optic cabling to 93% of Australian homes, schools and businesses, providing broadband speeds of up to 100 Mbps, or up to 100 times faster than what many Australians are experiencing.
Construction for laying the fibre-optic backbone links in Australia has started and construction on the second release sites will begin in the first half of 2011.
Good start for Malaysia
Brown says the Australian NBN is in the early stages of rollout and the government still needs to complete its deal with Telstra before the network rollout can really move forward in a substantial fashion. Indeed, the Malaysian HSBB will very likely be completed even before NBN gets off the gate.
“Therefore, from a pricing and achievement perspective, it is reasonable to say that the HSBB network has gone pretty much as well as can be expected for such a big logistical project,” says Brown.
“There have been some technical issues and it has taken them (TM) a bit longer than they might have liked to start signing wholesale deals. But in comparison with Australia, there is no doubt that Malaysia's deployment has been more efficient,” he adds.
Brown says the key thing for the HSBB is that they are not trying to take on too large a project all at once. The decision to roll out to only 20% of the country in the first stage has kept the project to a “manageable size and prevented problems faced in Australia”.
The other market in the region deploying an NBN is, of course, Singapore where the entire country will have fibre-to-home access by early 2013.
“However, it is not really useful to make costing comparisons between Singapore and other regional markets given the small geographic size of the Singapore market which makes FTTH/B rollout there very cost-effective, and most certainly so compared to Malaysia or Australia,” says Brown.
Singapore model
The Singaporean government has been promoting the usage of broadband Internet access as part of its Intelligent Nation 2015 (iN2015) masterplan. Interestingly, Singapore like South Korea, also has impressive existing infrastructure and is one of the most wired countries.
Last year, Internet service providers in Singapore started rolling out the Next Generation Nationwide Broadband Network (NGNBN) service plans. The NGNBN supports high speeds of up to 1Gbps as it uses an optical-fibre network.
According to Infocomm Development Authority of Singapore (IDA), by 2012, homes and offices nationwide will be connected to Singapore's ultra high-speed and pervasive NGNBN. In two years, some 60% of homes and offices can have access to this new, pervasive, all-fibre network.
The Singapore government had in 2008 selected the proposal from OpenNet Consortium to design, build and operate the passive infrastructure for the NGNBN. The OpenNet consortium comprises Axia NetMedia Corp (30%), Singapore Telecommunications Ltd (30%), Singapore Press Holdings Ltd (25%) and SP Telecommunications Pte Ltd (15%).
The NGNBN will be capable of delivering speeds of up to 1Gbps and beyond. It was reported that OpenNet will invest S$1bil-S$2bil to design, build and maintain the network infrastructure, while the government will support its rollout with a funding of S$750mil.
OpenNet began the fibre rollout in 2009. The rollout is on schedule and is expected to achieve the target of 95% total coverage by mid-2012.
Based on estimates, there are over half a billion broadband subscribers worldwide (including all fixed access technologies) as at end last year. While Japan continues to lead the world in terms of the number of FTTx (fibre to the home or curb) subscribers; South Korea has the highest penetration in the world and is the first to reach over 50% penetration of households using FTTx.
According to international research firm Parks Associates, the demand for high-bandwidth applications will jump in the next few years as the number of households worldwide with broadband will reach close to 650 million by 2013. Asia-Pacific is the largest market, accounting for over 160 million subscribers, and is expected to have over 49% of the global market share by 2013.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/7/business/8616272&sec=business
By LEONG HUNG YEE
hungyee@thestar.com.my
AFTER a much publicised kick-off, high speed broadband (HSBB) access in various forms is starting to take shape in Malaysia. Of late, there has been a flurry of activity as service providers rush to provide fixed-line broadband by riding on Telekom Malaysia Bhd's (TM) infrastructure.
UK-based Informa Telecoms & Media senior analyst Tony Brown tells StarBizWeek that TM's UniFi service, which got off to a relatively slow start in terms of subscriber growth, is really starting to pick up and growth prospects look good.
“Now that Maxis Bhd is selling HSBB services and Celcom Axiata Bhd is also likely to start doing so by year-end, we are going to see a big shift of subscribers moving away from DSL (Digital Subscriber Line) services towards the HSBB network,” he says.
The RM11.3bil HSBB project, signed in September 2008, is a public-private partnership agreement between TM and the Government to develop next-generation HSBB infrastructure and services for the nation.
TM is forking out RM8.9bil while the Government is co-investing RM2.4bil on an incurred claims basis based on project milestones reached by TM.
By end-2012 in accordance with the completion of the first phase of the national HSBB project roll-out as agreed with the Government about 1.3 million premises will have access to the HSBB services.
According to the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), government plays a special role in many developing countries in creating demand for next-generation broadband services.
“Building up fixed broadband infrastructure typically involves large-scale investments over long-time horizons and the private sector benefits from more certain prospects in its attempts to finance and roll out such infrastructure.
The foresight to develop an ultra-fast broadband infrastructure is not only limited to Malaysia. Countries as diverse as Australia, Brazil, China and India have launched broadband initiatives respectively.
Elsewhere in the region, there are also a slew of activities happening with regard to HSBB. Some countries have already rolled out their HSBB while some are currently in the midst of developing the infrastructure.
“K-broadband”
Analysts say closing the broadband gap has become a priority for many governments.
South Korea has announced its plans to build a super broadband infrastructure with upload and download speeds of 1Gbps by 2013 through a fibre-optic cable. The project is reported to cost about US$24.5bil, and will largely be funded by the private sector.
The country, which prides itself as being one of the world's most wired countries, already has the best download speeds around the globe. “You will not fail to be impressed by the speed of the country's online connections,” says an analyst. The country is in fact in the process of developing an even faster broadband speed.
According to speedtest.net, South Korea's average download speed of 30.64Mbps currently ranks the first in the world. The results were obtained by analysing test data between March 30 and May 2. By comparison, Malaysia ranks 102 with an average download speed of 2.61Mbps.
Wired broadband, however, is just at the beginning in South Korea; the Korea Communications Commission (KCC) has plans to ramp up its wireless broadband to 10Mbps.
Indeed, it would be interesting to see how things shape up in South Korea once the fibre-optic infrastructure is rolled out.
“At the rate South Korea is going, it is quite possible that the nation will give us a glimpse of our own wired future,” he says. The Korean project, largely funded by the private sector, is key to growing the country's status as a middle-income nation after years of economic despair. Home-grown online gaming and entertainment have also boomed in South Korea as a result of its investment in broadband infrastructure.
Experience Down Under
Informa Telecoms & Media's Brown says the HSBB rollout in Malaysia is one of the most interesting “National Broadband Network” (NBN) type deployments thus far as it targets a very specific part of the nation; it only covers 20% of total homes with its 1.3 million homes passed target.
“However, this very specific targeting has enabled TM and the Government to bring the project in for just US$3.78bil which is way below what is being spent by the Australian government in its own NBN deployment,” he says.
The Australian government plans to invest as much as A$43bil over eight years to build a high-speed Internet network to connect 90% of the nation's homes and create jobs.
The Australian government has also created a new company, NBN Co Ltd, to build and operate the broadband network in urban, regional and rural areas. The government will own at least 51% of a company that will make initial investments of A$4.7bil to build and operate the network.
NBN Co says the capital expenditure for the project is estimated at A$35.9bil, of which the Australian government's contribution will be A$27.5bil in equity in the project.
The NBN will involve the laying of fibre-optic cabling to 93% of Australian homes, schools and businesses, providing broadband speeds of up to 100 Mbps, or up to 100 times faster than what many Australians are experiencing.
Construction for laying the fibre-optic backbone links in Australia has started and construction on the second release sites will begin in the first half of 2011.
Good start for Malaysia
Brown says the Australian NBN is in the early stages of rollout and the government still needs to complete its deal with Telstra before the network rollout can really move forward in a substantial fashion. Indeed, the Malaysian HSBB will very likely be completed even before NBN gets off the gate.
“Therefore, from a pricing and achievement perspective, it is reasonable to say that the HSBB network has gone pretty much as well as can be expected for such a big logistical project,” says Brown.
“There have been some technical issues and it has taken them (TM) a bit longer than they might have liked to start signing wholesale deals. But in comparison with Australia, there is no doubt that Malaysia's deployment has been more efficient,” he adds.
Brown says the key thing for the HSBB is that they are not trying to take on too large a project all at once. The decision to roll out to only 20% of the country in the first stage has kept the project to a “manageable size and prevented problems faced in Australia”.
The other market in the region deploying an NBN is, of course, Singapore where the entire country will have fibre-to-home access by early 2013.
“However, it is not really useful to make costing comparisons between Singapore and other regional markets given the small geographic size of the Singapore market which makes FTTH/B rollout there very cost-effective, and most certainly so compared to Malaysia or Australia,” says Brown.
Singapore model
The Singaporean government has been promoting the usage of broadband Internet access as part of its Intelligent Nation 2015 (iN2015) masterplan. Interestingly, Singapore like South Korea, also has impressive existing infrastructure and is one of the most wired countries.
Last year, Internet service providers in Singapore started rolling out the Next Generation Nationwide Broadband Network (NGNBN) service plans. The NGNBN supports high speeds of up to 1Gbps as it uses an optical-fibre network.
According to Infocomm Development Authority of Singapore (IDA), by 2012, homes and offices nationwide will be connected to Singapore's ultra high-speed and pervasive NGNBN. In two years, some 60% of homes and offices can have access to this new, pervasive, all-fibre network.
The Singapore government had in 2008 selected the proposal from OpenNet Consortium to design, build and operate the passive infrastructure for the NGNBN. The OpenNet consortium comprises Axia NetMedia Corp (30%), Singapore Telecommunications Ltd (30%), Singapore Press Holdings Ltd (25%) and SP Telecommunications Pte Ltd (15%).
The NGNBN will be capable of delivering speeds of up to 1Gbps and beyond. It was reported that OpenNet will invest S$1bil-S$2bil to design, build and maintain the network infrastructure, while the government will support its rollout with a funding of S$750mil.
OpenNet began the fibre rollout in 2009. The rollout is on schedule and is expected to achieve the target of 95% total coverage by mid-2012.
Based on estimates, there are over half a billion broadband subscribers worldwide (including all fixed access technologies) as at end last year. While Japan continues to lead the world in terms of the number of FTTx (fibre to the home or curb) subscribers; South Korea has the highest penetration in the world and is the first to reach over 50% penetration of households using FTTx.
According to international research firm Parks Associates, the demand for high-bandwidth applications will jump in the next few years as the number of households worldwide with broadband will reach close to 650 million by 2013. Asia-Pacific is the largest market, accounting for over 160 million subscribers, and is expected to have over 49% of the global market share by 2013.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/7/business/8616272&sec=business
1Bestarinet should have Giga not Mega
Friday May 13, 2011
Friday Reflections - By B.K. Sidhu
WE can begin to leave SchoolNet behind us as a new tender to wire up schools with Internet broadband access is out.
This new project, known as 1Bestarinet, is supposed to wire up 9,924 schools in the country. The birth of 1Bestarinet dates back to the national key economic area telecoms lab days.
The tender bid was out on May 5 and a must-attend briefing was held on May 10. The closing date for the tender is May 31 this gives potential bidders three weeks to work on their proposals.
Some of those who want to be considered view the three weeks as too short for such a huge project that spans 10 years and can cost anything up to RM300,000 per year.
“Unless you had prior knowledge of this tender, it would be impossible for some parties to submit a tender as it covers a lot of areas and three weeks is just not enough,'' one said.
Nearly a dozen companies have collected the tender documents. They include players such as Celcom Axiata, Jaring, HighTech Padu, Maxis Bhd, REDTone International, Time dotCom, Telekom Malaysia and YTL Communications.
This tender is called by the Ministry of Education and it is clearly stipulated that it is open to local companies and preference will be given to bumiputra tender bids that are registered with the Finance Ministry under some codes stipulated.
To recap, SchoolNet was born in 2004 to wire up schools using wireless or fibre technology. Several companies won the bids to provide Internet access to the schools and while the effort was put in, there is really not much to gloat about. The effort is fruitless if it does not achieve its objective and we can blame the lack of specifications to lack of integration, unpreparedness of teachers and find all the flaws but a key component that did not make it shine was the access speed and capacity.
Then comes 1Bestarinet.
There are two major components access and learning management system (LMS) module. Many did not expect the LMS to be included but it is there and details need to be furnished with the tender bid.
For urban areas the access speed is 2Mbps to 10Mbps, and for rural and remote schools 1Mbps to 4Mbps. All sorts of technologies can be used, be it fibre or wireless technology including Vsat.
The interesting part is that even before the tender came out some parties have been burning the midnight oil to get prepared. One company managed to get a LMS module in place and it is dangling its carrot to work with others. Two others the ones with the biggest fibre networks are likely to put in a joint bid and have been on it for a while now.
But those who only got wind of it days before the tender opened, they will be scrambling to meet the deadline.
The contention is on timing why only three weeks when it is such a big project? Three weeks happens to be the minimum time required for a tender to remain opened.
One of the flaws of SchoolNet was scalability. That apparently is also the issue with 1Bestarinet even though some claim that those making a submission should consider cloud computing as an option.
While the 1Bestarinet project is great, did it take into consideration the murid's perspective?
We are talking about a group of people who will be tomorrow's leaders and they are the ones living in the era of social media, super fast Internet speed, smartphones, TouTube and so on, and for all that they need big capacity and super speed.
So 2Mbps or even 10Mbps is really not enough in a classroom of 30 to 40 students, the networks are going to be congested in no time. So should we pour money into networks that are only good for a year, two or three?
What we need to look at is the bare minimum of 1Gbps; there should be no compromises on speed and capacity. Taking U-turns can be a costly affair and it can delay us from reaching our destination.
Perhaps we ought to review our offering, make the change and give more time to those who are interested in the tender bid so that we can attract the best. While at it we should not consider players that don't keep their promises.
Deputy news editor B.K. Sidhu wishes all teachers a Happy Teacher's Day and thanks them for taking care of our children.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/13/business/8675705
Friday Reflections - By B.K. Sidhu
WE can begin to leave SchoolNet behind us as a new tender to wire up schools with Internet broadband access is out.
This new project, known as 1Bestarinet, is supposed to wire up 9,924 schools in the country. The birth of 1Bestarinet dates back to the national key economic area telecoms lab days.
The tender bid was out on May 5 and a must-attend briefing was held on May 10. The closing date for the tender is May 31 this gives potential bidders three weeks to work on their proposals.
Some of those who want to be considered view the three weeks as too short for such a huge project that spans 10 years and can cost anything up to RM300,000 per year.
“Unless you had prior knowledge of this tender, it would be impossible for some parties to submit a tender as it covers a lot of areas and three weeks is just not enough,'' one said.
Nearly a dozen companies have collected the tender documents. They include players such as Celcom Axiata, Jaring, HighTech Padu, Maxis Bhd, REDTone International, Time dotCom, Telekom Malaysia and YTL Communications.
This tender is called by the Ministry of Education and it is clearly stipulated that it is open to local companies and preference will be given to bumiputra tender bids that are registered with the Finance Ministry under some codes stipulated.
To recap, SchoolNet was born in 2004 to wire up schools using wireless or fibre technology. Several companies won the bids to provide Internet access to the schools and while the effort was put in, there is really not much to gloat about. The effort is fruitless if it does not achieve its objective and we can blame the lack of specifications to lack of integration, unpreparedness of teachers and find all the flaws but a key component that did not make it shine was the access speed and capacity.
Then comes 1Bestarinet.
There are two major components access and learning management system (LMS) module. Many did not expect the LMS to be included but it is there and details need to be furnished with the tender bid.
For urban areas the access speed is 2Mbps to 10Mbps, and for rural and remote schools 1Mbps to 4Mbps. All sorts of technologies can be used, be it fibre or wireless technology including Vsat.
The interesting part is that even before the tender came out some parties have been burning the midnight oil to get prepared. One company managed to get a LMS module in place and it is dangling its carrot to work with others. Two others the ones with the biggest fibre networks are likely to put in a joint bid and have been on it for a while now.
But those who only got wind of it days before the tender opened, they will be scrambling to meet the deadline.
The contention is on timing why only three weeks when it is such a big project? Three weeks happens to be the minimum time required for a tender to remain opened.
One of the flaws of SchoolNet was scalability. That apparently is also the issue with 1Bestarinet even though some claim that those making a submission should consider cloud computing as an option.
While the 1Bestarinet project is great, did it take into consideration the murid's perspective?
We are talking about a group of people who will be tomorrow's leaders and they are the ones living in the era of social media, super fast Internet speed, smartphones, TouTube and so on, and for all that they need big capacity and super speed.
So 2Mbps or even 10Mbps is really not enough in a classroom of 30 to 40 students, the networks are going to be congested in no time. So should we pour money into networks that are only good for a year, two or three?
What we need to look at is the bare minimum of 1Gbps; there should be no compromises on speed and capacity. Taking U-turns can be a costly affair and it can delay us from reaching our destination.
Perhaps we ought to review our offering, make the change and give more time to those who are interested in the tender bid so that we can attract the best. While at it we should not consider players that don't keep their promises.
Deputy news editor B.K. Sidhu wishes all teachers a Happy Teacher's Day and thanks them for taking care of our children.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/13/business/8675705
Poor Service a Bane to Telecom Sector
Saturday May 7, 2011
By LEONG HUNG YEE
hungyee@thestar.com.my
“TAKE it or leave it”. Sounds harsh? Believe it or not, that pretty much sums up the service level of certain local service providers in the country's telecommunications sector. Generally, while telcos and Internet service providers are striving to provide better user experience, poor service largely remains a huge headache for consumers. In fact, many consumers wonder if the rating scorecard they are occasionally asked to fill up by their respective telco providers actually is an exercise in futility, given the lack of improvement in the service quality.
When asked to comment on this, Telekom Malaysia Bhd (TM) group CEO Datuk Seri Zamzamzairani Mohd Isa says: “For me, because I am the CEO, I will never be satisfied with the service level ever. The idea is to have constant improvement. That's what we need to do.”
According to the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC), poor service makes up the bulk or 35% of consumers complaints, followed by content (16.7%), bill and charging (13.9%) and SMS (10.1%). The poor service coverage formed 3.5% of complaints recorded by the regulator and no service coverage 4.3%.
The high percentage of complaints due to poor service may not be a reflection of the real situation given that they only involve cases recorded by MCMC.
“There is a significant gap between expected and perceived service quality by service providers. There are many reasons for this. In some cases, it's the technical issue,” an analyst says.
Another analyst says there is no doubt that service quality in some areas is great but not in others. As such, more improvement needs to be done to solve consumer woes as opposed to collecting complaints and doing little about them.
“Perhaps the number is not reflective because people find it troublesome to file a complaint as they end up on the phone for at least 10 minutes, being entertained by some advertisement or music, before they can actually speak to someone,” says the analyst. “That in itself could form part of a complaint!” he quips.
Naturally, industry players acknowledge the fact that there's a gaping room for improvement in customer service levels and, as a result, continue to invest to provide customers with a better experience.
But in terms of service level, have they (service providers) “arrived”? “No”, says Celcom Axiata Bhd chief executive officer Datuk Seri Shazalli Ramly. “We need to build the foundation that will shift from voice to data first. That's what everybody is doing and must do. And that's what we are doing now. The foundation for better services is being built even as we speak. Before this, people thought they can use the voice foundation. It doesn't work anymore. It does not evolve as much as data,” Shazalli says, adding that Celcom has invested tremendously to improve its service level.
V for vandalism
“On the front, you've got to conduct training for the customers service, the systems, network and others. We are putting money into improving customers service,” Shazalli says, adding that there are glitches in the company's network due to rampant vandalism over the past year, causing it to lose RM40mil worth of equipment.
“There's rampant vandalism in the country. It is not just affecting us but the industry. Celcom has recorded more than 2,000 cases of vandalism, whereby 1,010 cases involved dropped calls and intermittent disruptions,” Shazalli says.
Of the 2,000 cases, 1,000 of those took more than a week a restore, he adds.
“And this is a national crisis for us. We rarely have dropped calls in areas like Sunway and then, boom, someone decided to steal something. This is one challenge. The minute the fibre is cut, the whole sector is disrupted and it's happening everyday with an average of 3 cases a day. They (vandals) think there is copper in there,” Shazalli says.
He says the other problem that Celcom is facing now is the restoration. “Two thousand cases means 2,000 people have to go on the ground to fix that problem. Those are the same engineers who built and maintain the network. Restoration takes more than seven days and that's not acceptable by the public. They want a maximum blackout of two hours!”
Maxis Bhd executive vice-president, network and technology Mark Dioguardi says its network is also affected by vandalism to a certain extent.
“We spent a lot of time on preventive and security measures. It happens every time and everywhere. It's affecting the industry,” he says, adding that Maxis has been hard at work to “repair things quickly”.
Dioguardi says vandalism is a huge challenge for the company, particularly in recent months. However, he admits that consumers may also experience service interruption due to scheduled service maintenance and upgrading of software, but such routine work is usually carried out in the wee hours of the morning where less people will be affected.
Operational challenges
Zamzamzairani says TM is constantly improving Unifi's service level but for the time being, there is no data on the nature of the complaints.
“We don't have the numbers yet. UniFi is a new service and we are tracking.”
“Putting in UniFi is not the same. You have to put fibre at home so the installation will take a bit longer and it's tougher to do,” he says.
Zamzamzairani acknowledges problems such as missed appointments by contractors and customers complaints, among others.
“Missed appointment for example. We promised we will come but never show up. I agree ... there are pockets. We listen to them and we are taking action. The key is constant improvement. More than anyone I would like to work on it. We just have to keep working on it to make sure it's happening,” he says.
Shazalli says customers touch points are one of the factors that set one telco apart from the other. “Where do you go when you have data problem? We need customers touch points to solve problems related to pure data only or you have to go to the phone store and talk to the dealer ... a lot of that is happening. Going forward, you will see phone shop and data services shop merge into one as we speak.”
“If you do the checklist from one to 10, we are about six. It's still a long way to go. Six being all the foundations that we have in place. That's another four more points to get a perfect 10.''
At what cost?
While service level may be an issue consumers are forced to endure, they also need to contend with the steep pricing for fibre broadband service.
Some opine that the pricing for TM's UniFi packages appear high and the same goes for Maxis' Home Services a fixed-line broadband Internet service.
Understandably, both TM and Maxis have brushed aside market talk that there is a so-called cartel in pricing for their fibre broadband services.
“Absolutely not! If you look at the region, it is very competitive,” says Maxis' Dioguardi, adding that the deal Maxis has with TM is “good enough to sign” and there is no such condition that it has to price its packages similarly to TM.
Maxis is offering a standard package with a speed of 4Mbps and a quota of 30 GB for RM128. UniFi's entry level package is priced at RM149 per month and it comes with high-speed broadband, IPTV (Internet protocol TV), free voice calls and some other offerings.
TM's Zamzamzairani says there's “no way” the two players can form a price cartel as on the retail side, they are competitors.
“It is a value proposition on the packages offered to our subscribers. Our retail side are competing all-out to get customers,” he adds.
Your right as a consumer
Not be known to many consumers, there actually exists a service level agreement which spells out the commitment of service providers which binds them to meet the minimum performance promised, as per the agreement. If there are perceived breaches, consumers can file a complaint with the MCMC.
A quick check on MCMC's website revealed that the task is rather simple. MCMC provides an online complaint communication channel for consumers to lodge complaints on any issues related to the communications and multimedia sector. It has also listed the other communication options for consumers to get in touch with the regulator.
Clearly, a great deal more needs to be done by local service providers. The end result, of course, is a win-win for consumers and telecom players.
http://www.blogger.com/post-create.g?blogID=3939847873441920399
By LEONG HUNG YEE
hungyee@thestar.com.my
“TAKE it or leave it”. Sounds harsh? Believe it or not, that pretty much sums up the service level of certain local service providers in the country's telecommunications sector. Generally, while telcos and Internet service providers are striving to provide better user experience, poor service largely remains a huge headache for consumers. In fact, many consumers wonder if the rating scorecard they are occasionally asked to fill up by their respective telco providers actually is an exercise in futility, given the lack of improvement in the service quality.
When asked to comment on this, Telekom Malaysia Bhd (TM) group CEO Datuk Seri Zamzamzairani Mohd Isa says: “For me, because I am the CEO, I will never be satisfied with the service level ever. The idea is to have constant improvement. That's what we need to do.”
According to the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC), poor service makes up the bulk or 35% of consumers complaints, followed by content (16.7%), bill and charging (13.9%) and SMS (10.1%). The poor service coverage formed 3.5% of complaints recorded by the regulator and no service coverage 4.3%.
The high percentage of complaints due to poor service may not be a reflection of the real situation given that they only involve cases recorded by MCMC.
“There is a significant gap between expected and perceived service quality by service providers. There are many reasons for this. In some cases, it's the technical issue,” an analyst says.
Another analyst says there is no doubt that service quality in some areas is great but not in others. As such, more improvement needs to be done to solve consumer woes as opposed to collecting complaints and doing little about them.
“Perhaps the number is not reflective because people find it troublesome to file a complaint as they end up on the phone for at least 10 minutes, being entertained by some advertisement or music, before they can actually speak to someone,” says the analyst. “That in itself could form part of a complaint!” he quips.
Naturally, industry players acknowledge the fact that there's a gaping room for improvement in customer service levels and, as a result, continue to invest to provide customers with a better experience.
But in terms of service level, have they (service providers) “arrived”? “No”, says Celcom Axiata Bhd chief executive officer Datuk Seri Shazalli Ramly. “We need to build the foundation that will shift from voice to data first. That's what everybody is doing and must do. And that's what we are doing now. The foundation for better services is being built even as we speak. Before this, people thought they can use the voice foundation. It doesn't work anymore. It does not evolve as much as data,” Shazalli says, adding that Celcom has invested tremendously to improve its service level.
V for vandalism
“On the front, you've got to conduct training for the customers service, the systems, network and others. We are putting money into improving customers service,” Shazalli says, adding that there are glitches in the company's network due to rampant vandalism over the past year, causing it to lose RM40mil worth of equipment.
“There's rampant vandalism in the country. It is not just affecting us but the industry. Celcom has recorded more than 2,000 cases of vandalism, whereby 1,010 cases involved dropped calls and intermittent disruptions,” Shazalli says.
Of the 2,000 cases, 1,000 of those took more than a week a restore, he adds.
“And this is a national crisis for us. We rarely have dropped calls in areas like Sunway and then, boom, someone decided to steal something. This is one challenge. The minute the fibre is cut, the whole sector is disrupted and it's happening everyday with an average of 3 cases a day. They (vandals) think there is copper in there,” Shazalli says.
He says the other problem that Celcom is facing now is the restoration. “Two thousand cases means 2,000 people have to go on the ground to fix that problem. Those are the same engineers who built and maintain the network. Restoration takes more than seven days and that's not acceptable by the public. They want a maximum blackout of two hours!”
Maxis Bhd executive vice-president, network and technology Mark Dioguardi says its network is also affected by vandalism to a certain extent.
“We spent a lot of time on preventive and security measures. It happens every time and everywhere. It's affecting the industry,” he says, adding that Maxis has been hard at work to “repair things quickly”.
Dioguardi says vandalism is a huge challenge for the company, particularly in recent months. However, he admits that consumers may also experience service interruption due to scheduled service maintenance and upgrading of software, but such routine work is usually carried out in the wee hours of the morning where less people will be affected.
Operational challenges
Zamzamzairani says TM is constantly improving Unifi's service level but for the time being, there is no data on the nature of the complaints.
“We don't have the numbers yet. UniFi is a new service and we are tracking.”
“Putting in UniFi is not the same. You have to put fibre at home so the installation will take a bit longer and it's tougher to do,” he says.
Zamzamzairani acknowledges problems such as missed appointments by contractors and customers complaints, among others.
“Missed appointment for example. We promised we will come but never show up. I agree ... there are pockets. We listen to them and we are taking action. The key is constant improvement. More than anyone I would like to work on it. We just have to keep working on it to make sure it's happening,” he says.
Shazalli says customers touch points are one of the factors that set one telco apart from the other. “Where do you go when you have data problem? We need customers touch points to solve problems related to pure data only or you have to go to the phone store and talk to the dealer ... a lot of that is happening. Going forward, you will see phone shop and data services shop merge into one as we speak.”
“If you do the checklist from one to 10, we are about six. It's still a long way to go. Six being all the foundations that we have in place. That's another four more points to get a perfect 10.''
At what cost?
While service level may be an issue consumers are forced to endure, they also need to contend with the steep pricing for fibre broadband service.
Some opine that the pricing for TM's UniFi packages appear high and the same goes for Maxis' Home Services a fixed-line broadband Internet service.
Understandably, both TM and Maxis have brushed aside market talk that there is a so-called cartel in pricing for their fibre broadband services.
“Absolutely not! If you look at the region, it is very competitive,” says Maxis' Dioguardi, adding that the deal Maxis has with TM is “good enough to sign” and there is no such condition that it has to price its packages similarly to TM.
Maxis is offering a standard package with a speed of 4Mbps and a quota of 30 GB for RM128. UniFi's entry level package is priced at RM149 per month and it comes with high-speed broadband, IPTV (Internet protocol TV), free voice calls and some other offerings.
TM's Zamzamzairani says there's “no way” the two players can form a price cartel as on the retail side, they are competitors.
“It is a value proposition on the packages offered to our subscribers. Our retail side are competing all-out to get customers,” he adds.
Your right as a consumer
Not be known to many consumers, there actually exists a service level agreement which spells out the commitment of service providers which binds them to meet the minimum performance promised, as per the agreement. If there are perceived breaches, consumers can file a complaint with the MCMC.
A quick check on MCMC's website revealed that the task is rather simple. MCMC provides an online complaint communication channel for consumers to lodge complaints on any issues related to the communications and multimedia sector. It has also listed the other communication options for consumers to get in touch with the regulator.
Clearly, a great deal more needs to be done by local service providers. The end result, of course, is a win-win for consumers and telecom players.
http://www.blogger.com/post-create.g?blogID=3939847873441920399
The Long Wait for HSBB
Saturday May 7, 2011
A QUESTION OF BUSINESS By P. GUNASEGARAM
p.guna@thestar.com.my
We must not kid ourselves that the journey towards this is going to be an easy one
The figures may be impressive at first glance but closer examination indicates that not all's well with Telekom Malaysia's plans to implement high speed broadband (HSBB) across the country and even in urban areas in and around Kuala Lumpur (see our cover story this week).
In its first year, TM's broadband service, Unifi, garnered 60,000 subscribers (as at March 24), not particularly impressive. But TM claims that 800,000 premises in 61 exchange areas can access the service that is impressive. The target is 1.3 million premises by 2012.
Question: Why have just a mere 7.5% who could have Unifi services subscribed to it? At this rate, broadband penetration rates for Malaysia, already very low, will continue to be so for many more years to come.
Next question: Doesn't TM have actual subscription targets for Unifi and if it does, what are they? It's easy to claim coverage, but difficult to verify. It's the number of people who use the service that counts. If there is no take-up, service availability is of no consequence.
Bear in mind that TM has 1.7 million broadband customers and just 60,000 Unifi users (as at March 24). At the current rate of take-up of Unifi, it will take 30 years before TM can convert all its current broadband users to Unifi! That's alarming.
Sometimes anecdotal evidence helps where statistics seem to be claiming too much. Residents of Damansara Heights in Kuala Lumpur would be more than aware that their roads have undergone constant digging for some months now (at least four months).
The reason is that a major telecommunications company is laying fibre in the ground and soon the houses in that area will have HSBB access. Question is how soon? If it takes six months to a year to fibre up an area as small as Damansara Heights, how long will it take for the whole of Kuala Lumpur?
Next, folks will remember that TM started its Unifi service in March 2009 in four areas in the Klang Valley - Shah Alam, Subang Jaya, Taman Tun Dr Ismail and Bangsar.
But residents at the relatively new housing area of Setia Eco Park in Shah Alam will testify that there is no Unifi service there until today. How come when Shah Alam was supposed to have Unifi service more than a year ago? It just does not figure.
We should be clear about certain things when it comes to HSBB. First, we are way behind time and have lost many years and lag very far behind major countries in the world. Even in urban areas, we have not been able to provide adequate services comparable to major cities.
Second, we need to accelerate the take-up rate for HSBB by providing services in all urban areas at least at a very rapid rate and at affordable prices. Third, we need to put plans in place for the next generation systems now and plans for implementation.
HSBB is major infrastructure sorely needed to push our knowledge base, communications, competitiveness and productivity up. As a relatively small country we need to maximise resources and avoid duplication the way we did when we granted a slew of licences for telecommunications companies and saw a proliferation of fibre optic networks with no ability to deliver the last mile to homes and offices.
The development of such infrastructure should not be left to a single company, and one too which is not particularly noted for either its innovation or excellence in planning, formulation and execution.
The Government should seriously consider putting all resources for this important backbone of communication into a single new company to be headed by an independent and competent management team with ownership by the Government and all major users, especially the telecommunications companies.
The devil will be in the details but that is something that has to be worked out. Otherwise, the cost will be too great in the long term. Remember, we are way behind as it is.
Managing editor P Gunasegaram says that critical situations call for bold solutions.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/7/business/8634202
A QUESTION OF BUSINESS By P. GUNASEGARAM
p.guna@thestar.com.my
We must not kid ourselves that the journey towards this is going to be an easy one
The figures may be impressive at first glance but closer examination indicates that not all's well with Telekom Malaysia's plans to implement high speed broadband (HSBB) across the country and even in urban areas in and around Kuala Lumpur (see our cover story this week).
In its first year, TM's broadband service, Unifi, garnered 60,000 subscribers (as at March 24), not particularly impressive. But TM claims that 800,000 premises in 61 exchange areas can access the service that is impressive. The target is 1.3 million premises by 2012.
Question: Why have just a mere 7.5% who could have Unifi services subscribed to it? At this rate, broadband penetration rates for Malaysia, already very low, will continue to be so for many more years to come.
Next question: Doesn't TM have actual subscription targets for Unifi and if it does, what are they? It's easy to claim coverage, but difficult to verify. It's the number of people who use the service that counts. If there is no take-up, service availability is of no consequence.
Bear in mind that TM has 1.7 million broadband customers and just 60,000 Unifi users (as at March 24). At the current rate of take-up of Unifi, it will take 30 years before TM can convert all its current broadband users to Unifi! That's alarming.
Sometimes anecdotal evidence helps where statistics seem to be claiming too much. Residents of Damansara Heights in Kuala Lumpur would be more than aware that their roads have undergone constant digging for some months now (at least four months).
The reason is that a major telecommunications company is laying fibre in the ground and soon the houses in that area will have HSBB access. Question is how soon? If it takes six months to a year to fibre up an area as small as Damansara Heights, how long will it take for the whole of Kuala Lumpur?
Next, folks will remember that TM started its Unifi service in March 2009 in four areas in the Klang Valley - Shah Alam, Subang Jaya, Taman Tun Dr Ismail and Bangsar.
But residents at the relatively new housing area of Setia Eco Park in Shah Alam will testify that there is no Unifi service there until today. How come when Shah Alam was supposed to have Unifi service more than a year ago? It just does not figure.
We should be clear about certain things when it comes to HSBB. First, we are way behind time and have lost many years and lag very far behind major countries in the world. Even in urban areas, we have not been able to provide adequate services comparable to major cities.
Second, we need to accelerate the take-up rate for HSBB by providing services in all urban areas at least at a very rapid rate and at affordable prices. Third, we need to put plans in place for the next generation systems now and plans for implementation.
HSBB is major infrastructure sorely needed to push our knowledge base, communications, competitiveness and productivity up. As a relatively small country we need to maximise resources and avoid duplication the way we did when we granted a slew of licences for telecommunications companies and saw a proliferation of fibre optic networks with no ability to deliver the last mile to homes and offices.
The development of such infrastructure should not be left to a single company, and one too which is not particularly noted for either its innovation or excellence in planning, formulation and execution.
The Government should seriously consider putting all resources for this important backbone of communication into a single new company to be headed by an independent and competent management team with ownership by the Government and all major users, especially the telecommunications companies.
The devil will be in the details but that is something that has to be worked out. Otherwise, the cost will be too great in the long term. Remember, we are way behind as it is.
Managing editor P Gunasegaram says that critical situations call for bold solutions.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/7/business/8634202
Broadening Access
Saturday May 7, 2011
By B.K. SIDHU
bksidhu@thestar.com.my
Just about a year since its launch of Unifi, how well is TM faring?
CANNOT stop griping, if you don't have it. Love it, if you do. That aptly sums up the reaction to Telekom Malaysia Bhd's (TM) retail highspeed broadband service (HSBB) called Unifi, launched over a year ago.
Those who reside in the hub of Klang Valley but do not have access to Unifi do not understand why there are still areas without decent HSBB access. On the other hand, if you were to talk to those who have already hopped onto HSBB's super-fast service, their reactions and feedback are surely an envy.
Meanwhile, the much-improved mobile access and smartphones, and the phenomenal popularity of bandwidth intensive applications such as online video, IP-based telephone services to downloads of music/video files are resulting in rapid lifestyle changes.
Mark Dioguardi says Maxis will continue to invest.
Against this backdrop, when Unifi was launched in March 2010, it was a highly-anticipated and glitzy event. Expectations were high largely due to the pent-up demand among data-hungry users.
Upon closer examination though, it may appear as if the numbers don't quite stack up against the total cost of the HSBB's project of RM11.3bil which will span over 10 years. As it stands today, TM, which co-owns and operates the HSBB, has drawn 80,000 users for the service. However, this is only 10% of the 800,000 premises where the services are currently available. This means that the HSBB has catered for 800,000 users in either offices or homes but only 80,000 have subscribed to it.
In its defence, TM is insistent that growth at current levels is commendable. “How can you tell if we are slow or fast within a year? (You should) Benchmark us with others, especially the European players ... you will see that their growth numbers are only 2%-3% for similar rollouts over the first year. Ours is almost 10%,'' says TM group CEO Datuk Seri Zamzamzairani Mohd Isa in an interview.
The Government has forked out RM2.4bil of the total cost of the project, whose main objective is to propel the nation towards a knowledge wealthy one and cater for the massive and ever rising bandwidth demand. The contribution towards economic growth cannot be emphasised enough as well. Based on estimates, for every 10% increase in broadband penetration, GDP could be boosted by an average 1.3%.
Unifi (on it's own) may not be able to meet the demands of all consumers, but together with Streamyx service, TM may be able to do so and the two services could amass a sizeable subscriber population. As at the end of last year the broadband household penetration rates in the country reached 55%. TM contributed to over 50% of that and expects to remain the major contributor in the future, says Zam.
Low speed on implementation?
An analyst who tracks the telco sector opines that TM may be moving too slowly in their pursuit of subscribers, especially given that it has so much capacity ready for retail take-up.
Nomura Research analyst Sachin Gupta from Singapore believes that “it is all about winning customers and Unifi has so many homes passed but the (subscriber numbers) are nothing (great).''
Afzal Abdul Rahim says the second network may not be a viable proposition.
As at the end of last year and six months into its roll out, Unifi had 33,000 users. Net additions over the past four months have been impressive at more than 10,000 subscribers per month. Of the 80,000 users, 70% of users migrated from TM Steamyx to Unifi while the remaining 30% are new customers.
“You must remember that this is a 10-year project and it is to provide premises passed so that the country can have an infrastructure sooner rather than later. It is based on a supply driven model, and the focus is on roll-out. We are doing quite well and trying to get as many take-ups as we can,'' Zam says.
Apart from the 95 areas covered under the public/private partnership between the government and TM for the total 1.3 million premises rollout, TM will expand to other areas where there is demand for Unifi.
“This will also affect our demand and take up projections and all in all we expect the future of HSBB to be bright,'' says Zam.
The targets are intact. By year end, he expects Unifi to have 150,000 subscribers with 1.1 million premises passed. By the end of 2012, it expects to extend its services to 1.3 million premises. Currently, Unifi is available in 63 areas and by year end, this is expected to rise to 78 and by the end of 2012 to 95.
Even so, the perception that the roll out is slower than it ought to be persists.
“People have not warmed up to UniFi and the high speeds it provides due to a combination of reasons. Firstly, the market is a price sensitive one and with that, current users of DSL (direct subscriber line) broadband have not seen the need to pay more for the high speeds. This points to another issue and that is potential subscribers are not able to see the ways in which they can fully utilize the larger pipe. Therefore, access to content that leverages on high speed broadband needs to be strengthened.'' says IDC Malaysia associate market analyst John Cheah.
Tipping Point
Tony Brown, a senior analyst at a UK-based research company Informa Telecoms & Media, says that, “we have seen that fibre-to-the-home (FTTH) take up rate on a regional basis is usually governed by FTTH operators offering prices that are at par with existing DSL and only a few subscribers are actually willing to pay a premium for the higher speeds that FTTH offers.''
On that note, an analyst opines that TM should reduce the entry level packages to below RM100/month.
Naturally, Zam thinks otherwise as “demand is there and so is the value. It is triple play and not just about HSBB ... it's about Internet, video and phone.'' In fact, Zam points out that Unifi's 5Mpbs package is priced lower than that of its rival Time dotCom Bhd (TDC).
Brown points out that Maxis offers a cheaper headline HSBB package than TM. However, that may not necessarily be the case. Maxis offers 4Mbps with 30GB of data for RM128/month whilst TM offers 5Mbps with 60GB of data for RM149/month; that is double the data for only RM21 more per month and TM's offer also includes IPTV and voice.
As such, for consumers hoping that TM would tweak its pricing downwards anytime soon, could be in for a disappointment.
Zam admits that there are challenges in operation and execution of FTTH projects such as logistics and training that continue to bog the company in its quest to roll out faster.
Datuk Seri Shazalli Ramly ... ‘You have to move because of the evolution
Indeed, digging up roads to lay fibre in the ground can be a costly affair, although for new townships, this would naturally be a lot easier to do.
In reality, most parts of the Klang Valley are “brown field'' areas, which means digging and laying of fibre takes up a relatively long time and it is this which Cheah says could be delaying TM's efforts to link users up to the fibre, although 800,000 premises can already tap into the super-fast broadband service.
Zam points out that for areas which do not have Unifi just yet, TM's Streamyx is made available. Besides, there are plenty of wireless options from Maxis Bhd, Celcom Axiata Bhd, DiGi.Com Bhd, Packet One Network (P1), YTL Communications, RedTone International Bhd and TDC.
Zam believes the growth experience over the past four months is “an indication that the take up is ramping up.''
“We want to do more and we will not take years to fill the 1.3 million premises passed. We are building and the demand is there. The inflection point is 200,000 users and then everything goes up. We should hit that inflexion point in 2012,'' he says.
TM's management's guidance to analyst is that its margins will be weaker this year due to higher marketing cost but margins are expected to be higher in the following years at the operating level.
Homing in on consumers
Of late, the hottest buzz in the high speed broadband realm is in the home services sector where reaching out to more users in a single household instead of satisfying the needs of just one user is the order of the day. The development in technology allows for this while the behavioural changes among consumers are driving the need to diversify. With aggregation of content, telcos and celcos are moving to generate better revenues for their fibre.
Consumers need more and better options. For example, a television set which is traditionally there for passive viewing, hence often referred to as the idiot box', is evolving into an interactive and gaming device.
It is the changes in demands which observers say could have led to TM's decision to relax its stranglehold on HSBB services and reconsider its seven-year moratorium which was aimed at fending off competition, to finally open its doors to Maxis late last year. TM is also currently drawing up a similar deal with Celcom.
An analyst says it was also the lukewarm response to Unifi and enterprise business that could have driven TM to capitalise on its asset by opening it up to its competitors.
“A lot of money has been invested into HSBB and a healthy rate of return is more important than other initial strategies. At this point, it is beneficial for TM to have a fibre partner as they can derive revenues from the wholesale business,'' says IDC's Cheah.
Whatever the reason, the move should be lauded as more players can only be a good thing for consumers as it brings about more choices.
Meanwhile, consumers are watching with anticipation what Maxis has planned for the home services products, although like most things that are preceded by high expectation, the offerings since the soft launch has yet to match expectations.
Michael Lai says the future will be driven by content in high definition, bigger bandwidth and multiple screens ...
“The big question really surrounds what kind of growth Maxis will be able to drive with its retail HSBB services since they have a track record of top-notch marketing. If they can replicate their success in the mobile market in HSBB, we could see some really strong growth,'' Tony says.
Yet some observers are curious as to why TM has not teamed up with Astro. Instead, Astro has tied up with TM's rival TDC to offer IPTV and broadband, which is in direct competition with TM.
Cheah says content is key to growth in take up and while TM has an impressive content library, this could be no match to that of Astro's.
Banding together
Brown adds that if Maxis deploys a powerful IPTV that includes some of Astro's exclusive content, that could clearly give it an edge over TM and Celcom. “TM's biggest problem in the HSBB era is clearly content. They just cannot break the grip that Astro holds and would probably want the MCMC to move in and do something about content rights, similar to what regulators have done in Singapore. But it's tough to see that happening,'' says Brown.
On his part, Zam says: “We will look to work with anyone who wants to work with us. We keep our options open. More content will help.''
Most certainly, it's exciting times for Malaysia as high speed Internet is the conduit to accelerate lifestyle changes. The big question is is there enough fibre to take us through the next generation or the next 5-10 years when man-to-man communications will completely shift gear to man-to-machines and machines-to-machines? Now, that's some food for thought.
“A lot of people do not understand the magnitude of the future growth. At this point, regulators around the world are already looking for more spectrum since growth is going to be exponential. Increasingly, the fibre and wireless/mobile players are forming collaborations to work together to meet the demand,'' says P1 CEO Michael Lai.
Globally, there are over 1 billion broadband users and more than half a billion fixed broadband users; the latter are expected to surge to 1 billion by 2013.
Lai adds that the “future will be driven by content in high definition, bigger bandwidth and multiple screens and no one player can handle these alone. So, they will compete and co-operate or what they call in the IT industry co-opetition.''
Celcom CEO Datuk Seri Shazalli Ramly adds that “we saw lots of agreements (between players) being signed and that means there is realisation, it is sinking into all players. If you don't, you get burnt as you no longer can stay at comfortable (levels). You have to move because of the evolution.''
Lai says while HSBB is a good starting point as fibre gives capacity, what is being offered today, such as 5Mbps, 10Mbps or even 20Mbps, is nowhere near future demands where the concept of smart grids and electrical applications being able to work independently come into play.
So, the next logical question could be is it time to plan a second independent superfast speed network to cater for future growth? That may be a welcoming idea for smaller players who currently find it a hassle to ride on the HSBB as TM prefers users who can add value.
To meet the burgeoning and ever-evolving demand, Maxis executive vice-president, network and technology Mark Dioguardi states the obvious when he says that the company will have to continue to invest.
As for the second network, TDC CEO Afzal Abdul Rahim says it may not be a viable proposition. Zam says: “If there is market failure, we would need to do something like that. But we can come to reasonable terms to provide choices, so why re-invent the wheel?''
Nomura's Sachin says there can never be enough fibre given the exponential data traffic growth. However, he says that given Malaysia's (comparatively small) size and population, it would be hard to justify having an alternative competing fixed infrastructure to the existing fibre.
Based on latest subscriber figures, TM has some way to go to bridge the Klang Valley's digital divide, let alone that of the nation, while execution clearly remains the top challenge.
While wireless and cellular players have higher broadband subscriber numbers, they would still have to depend on fibre for their core network and base stations from TM. On the retail side, however, they are competing with Unifi.
There is a school of thought that TM should spin off the wholesale business to an independent party to allow for a single pricing mechanism for all players and focus on retail to enable it to reach far and wide. That is something akin to what British Telecom did many years ago.
Of course, that's an option that TM would clearly not be in favour of.
“Different countries have different approaches. We cannot be compelled to do it just because one country has done it. What are we trying to achieve here dominance? That does not resolve the problem. In any case, there are players out there with more licences than us. They are capable of building their own,” says Zam.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/7/business/8612351
By B.K. SIDHU
bksidhu@thestar.com.my
Just about a year since its launch of Unifi, how well is TM faring?
CANNOT stop griping, if you don't have it. Love it, if you do. That aptly sums up the reaction to Telekom Malaysia Bhd's (TM) retail highspeed broadband service (HSBB) called Unifi, launched over a year ago.
Those who reside in the hub of Klang Valley but do not have access to Unifi do not understand why there are still areas without decent HSBB access. On the other hand, if you were to talk to those who have already hopped onto HSBB's super-fast service, their reactions and feedback are surely an envy.
Meanwhile, the much-improved mobile access and smartphones, and the phenomenal popularity of bandwidth intensive applications such as online video, IP-based telephone services to downloads of music/video files are resulting in rapid lifestyle changes.
Mark Dioguardi says Maxis will continue to invest.
Against this backdrop, when Unifi was launched in March 2010, it was a highly-anticipated and glitzy event. Expectations were high largely due to the pent-up demand among data-hungry users.
Upon closer examination though, it may appear as if the numbers don't quite stack up against the total cost of the HSBB's project of RM11.3bil which will span over 10 years. As it stands today, TM, which co-owns and operates the HSBB, has drawn 80,000 users for the service. However, this is only 10% of the 800,000 premises where the services are currently available. This means that the HSBB has catered for 800,000 users in either offices or homes but only 80,000 have subscribed to it.
In its defence, TM is insistent that growth at current levels is commendable. “How can you tell if we are slow or fast within a year? (You should) Benchmark us with others, especially the European players ... you will see that their growth numbers are only 2%-3% for similar rollouts over the first year. Ours is almost 10%,'' says TM group CEO Datuk Seri Zamzamzairani Mohd Isa in an interview.
The Government has forked out RM2.4bil of the total cost of the project, whose main objective is to propel the nation towards a knowledge wealthy one and cater for the massive and ever rising bandwidth demand. The contribution towards economic growth cannot be emphasised enough as well. Based on estimates, for every 10% increase in broadband penetration, GDP could be boosted by an average 1.3%.
Unifi (on it's own) may not be able to meet the demands of all consumers, but together with Streamyx service, TM may be able to do so and the two services could amass a sizeable subscriber population. As at the end of last year the broadband household penetration rates in the country reached 55%. TM contributed to over 50% of that and expects to remain the major contributor in the future, says Zam.
Low speed on implementation?
An analyst who tracks the telco sector opines that TM may be moving too slowly in their pursuit of subscribers, especially given that it has so much capacity ready for retail take-up.
Nomura Research analyst Sachin Gupta from Singapore believes that “it is all about winning customers and Unifi has so many homes passed but the (subscriber numbers) are nothing (great).''
Afzal Abdul Rahim says the second network may not be a viable proposition.
As at the end of last year and six months into its roll out, Unifi had 33,000 users. Net additions over the past four months have been impressive at more than 10,000 subscribers per month. Of the 80,000 users, 70% of users migrated from TM Steamyx to Unifi while the remaining 30% are new customers.
“You must remember that this is a 10-year project and it is to provide premises passed so that the country can have an infrastructure sooner rather than later. It is based on a supply driven model, and the focus is on roll-out. We are doing quite well and trying to get as many take-ups as we can,'' Zam says.
Apart from the 95 areas covered under the public/private partnership between the government and TM for the total 1.3 million premises rollout, TM will expand to other areas where there is demand for Unifi.
“This will also affect our demand and take up projections and all in all we expect the future of HSBB to be bright,'' says Zam.
The targets are intact. By year end, he expects Unifi to have 150,000 subscribers with 1.1 million premises passed. By the end of 2012, it expects to extend its services to 1.3 million premises. Currently, Unifi is available in 63 areas and by year end, this is expected to rise to 78 and by the end of 2012 to 95.
Even so, the perception that the roll out is slower than it ought to be persists.
“People have not warmed up to UniFi and the high speeds it provides due to a combination of reasons. Firstly, the market is a price sensitive one and with that, current users of DSL (direct subscriber line) broadband have not seen the need to pay more for the high speeds. This points to another issue and that is potential subscribers are not able to see the ways in which they can fully utilize the larger pipe. Therefore, access to content that leverages on high speed broadband needs to be strengthened.'' says IDC Malaysia associate market analyst John Cheah.
Tipping Point
Tony Brown, a senior analyst at a UK-based research company Informa Telecoms & Media, says that, “we have seen that fibre-to-the-home (FTTH) take up rate on a regional basis is usually governed by FTTH operators offering prices that are at par with existing DSL and only a few subscribers are actually willing to pay a premium for the higher speeds that FTTH offers.''
On that note, an analyst opines that TM should reduce the entry level packages to below RM100/month.
Naturally, Zam thinks otherwise as “demand is there and so is the value. It is triple play and not just about HSBB ... it's about Internet, video and phone.'' In fact, Zam points out that Unifi's 5Mpbs package is priced lower than that of its rival Time dotCom Bhd (TDC).
Brown points out that Maxis offers a cheaper headline HSBB package than TM. However, that may not necessarily be the case. Maxis offers 4Mbps with 30GB of data for RM128/month whilst TM offers 5Mbps with 60GB of data for RM149/month; that is double the data for only RM21 more per month and TM's offer also includes IPTV and voice.
As such, for consumers hoping that TM would tweak its pricing downwards anytime soon, could be in for a disappointment.
Zam admits that there are challenges in operation and execution of FTTH projects such as logistics and training that continue to bog the company in its quest to roll out faster.
Datuk Seri Shazalli Ramly ... ‘You have to move because of the evolution
Indeed, digging up roads to lay fibre in the ground can be a costly affair, although for new townships, this would naturally be a lot easier to do.
In reality, most parts of the Klang Valley are “brown field'' areas, which means digging and laying of fibre takes up a relatively long time and it is this which Cheah says could be delaying TM's efforts to link users up to the fibre, although 800,000 premises can already tap into the super-fast broadband service.
Zam points out that for areas which do not have Unifi just yet, TM's Streamyx is made available. Besides, there are plenty of wireless options from Maxis Bhd, Celcom Axiata Bhd, DiGi.Com Bhd, Packet One Network (P1), YTL Communications, RedTone International Bhd and TDC.
Zam believes the growth experience over the past four months is “an indication that the take up is ramping up.''
“We want to do more and we will not take years to fill the 1.3 million premises passed. We are building and the demand is there. The inflection point is 200,000 users and then everything goes up. We should hit that inflexion point in 2012,'' he says.
TM's management's guidance to analyst is that its margins will be weaker this year due to higher marketing cost but margins are expected to be higher in the following years at the operating level.
Homing in on consumers
Of late, the hottest buzz in the high speed broadband realm is in the home services sector where reaching out to more users in a single household instead of satisfying the needs of just one user is the order of the day. The development in technology allows for this while the behavioural changes among consumers are driving the need to diversify. With aggregation of content, telcos and celcos are moving to generate better revenues for their fibre.
Consumers need more and better options. For example, a television set which is traditionally there for passive viewing, hence often referred to as the idiot box', is evolving into an interactive and gaming device.
It is the changes in demands which observers say could have led to TM's decision to relax its stranglehold on HSBB services and reconsider its seven-year moratorium which was aimed at fending off competition, to finally open its doors to Maxis late last year. TM is also currently drawing up a similar deal with Celcom.
An analyst says it was also the lukewarm response to Unifi and enterprise business that could have driven TM to capitalise on its asset by opening it up to its competitors.
“A lot of money has been invested into HSBB and a healthy rate of return is more important than other initial strategies. At this point, it is beneficial for TM to have a fibre partner as they can derive revenues from the wholesale business,'' says IDC's Cheah.
Whatever the reason, the move should be lauded as more players can only be a good thing for consumers as it brings about more choices.
Meanwhile, consumers are watching with anticipation what Maxis has planned for the home services products, although like most things that are preceded by high expectation, the offerings since the soft launch has yet to match expectations.
Michael Lai says the future will be driven by content in high definition, bigger bandwidth and multiple screens ...
“The big question really surrounds what kind of growth Maxis will be able to drive with its retail HSBB services since they have a track record of top-notch marketing. If they can replicate their success in the mobile market in HSBB, we could see some really strong growth,'' Tony says.
Yet some observers are curious as to why TM has not teamed up with Astro. Instead, Astro has tied up with TM's rival TDC to offer IPTV and broadband, which is in direct competition with TM.
Cheah says content is key to growth in take up and while TM has an impressive content library, this could be no match to that of Astro's.
Banding together
Brown adds that if Maxis deploys a powerful IPTV that includes some of Astro's exclusive content, that could clearly give it an edge over TM and Celcom. “TM's biggest problem in the HSBB era is clearly content. They just cannot break the grip that Astro holds and would probably want the MCMC to move in and do something about content rights, similar to what regulators have done in Singapore. But it's tough to see that happening,'' says Brown.
On his part, Zam says: “We will look to work with anyone who wants to work with us. We keep our options open. More content will help.''
Most certainly, it's exciting times for Malaysia as high speed Internet is the conduit to accelerate lifestyle changes. The big question is is there enough fibre to take us through the next generation or the next 5-10 years when man-to-man communications will completely shift gear to man-to-machines and machines-to-machines? Now, that's some food for thought.
“A lot of people do not understand the magnitude of the future growth. At this point, regulators around the world are already looking for more spectrum since growth is going to be exponential. Increasingly, the fibre and wireless/mobile players are forming collaborations to work together to meet the demand,'' says P1 CEO Michael Lai.
Globally, there are over 1 billion broadband users and more than half a billion fixed broadband users; the latter are expected to surge to 1 billion by 2013.
Lai adds that the “future will be driven by content in high definition, bigger bandwidth and multiple screens and no one player can handle these alone. So, they will compete and co-operate or what they call in the IT industry co-opetition.''
Celcom CEO Datuk Seri Shazalli Ramly adds that “we saw lots of agreements (between players) being signed and that means there is realisation, it is sinking into all players. If you don't, you get burnt as you no longer can stay at comfortable (levels). You have to move because of the evolution.''
Lai says while HSBB is a good starting point as fibre gives capacity, what is being offered today, such as 5Mbps, 10Mbps or even 20Mbps, is nowhere near future demands where the concept of smart grids and electrical applications being able to work independently come into play.
So, the next logical question could be is it time to plan a second independent superfast speed network to cater for future growth? That may be a welcoming idea for smaller players who currently find it a hassle to ride on the HSBB as TM prefers users who can add value.
To meet the burgeoning and ever-evolving demand, Maxis executive vice-president, network and technology Mark Dioguardi states the obvious when he says that the company will have to continue to invest.
As for the second network, TDC CEO Afzal Abdul Rahim says it may not be a viable proposition. Zam says: “If there is market failure, we would need to do something like that. But we can come to reasonable terms to provide choices, so why re-invent the wheel?''
Nomura's Sachin says there can never be enough fibre given the exponential data traffic growth. However, he says that given Malaysia's (comparatively small) size and population, it would be hard to justify having an alternative competing fixed infrastructure to the existing fibre.
Based on latest subscriber figures, TM has some way to go to bridge the Klang Valley's digital divide, let alone that of the nation, while execution clearly remains the top challenge.
While wireless and cellular players have higher broadband subscriber numbers, they would still have to depend on fibre for their core network and base stations from TM. On the retail side, however, they are competing with Unifi.
There is a school of thought that TM should spin off the wholesale business to an independent party to allow for a single pricing mechanism for all players and focus on retail to enable it to reach far and wide. That is something akin to what British Telecom did many years ago.
Of course, that's an option that TM would clearly not be in favour of.
“Different countries have different approaches. We cannot be compelled to do it just because one country has done it. What are we trying to achieve here dominance? That does not resolve the problem. In any case, there are players out there with more licences than us. They are capable of building their own,” says Zam.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/7/business/8612351
KRS – an alliance of telco rivals
Saturday April 30, 2011
By B.K. SIDHU
bksidhu@thestar.com.my
INDEED, it is rare when two dozen telcos come together for a common goal. Instead of pulling away in different directions, a competitive industry can also compel rivals within the same industry to forge alliances.
On Monday, an agreement was inked to set up a 24-member Konsortium Rangkaian Serantau Sdn Bhd (KRS) which has a paid up capital RM240,000, thanks to the RM10,000 contribution from each member.
The telcos include Telekom Malaysia Bhd (TM), Time Dotcom Bhd (TDC), Maxis Bhd, Celcom Axiata Bhd, DiGi.Com Bhd, U Mobile Sdn Bhd, Green Packet, YTL Communications Sdn Bhd, RedTone International Bhd, OCE, Fibrerail Sdn Bhd, Jaring, Sacofa, Sarawak Information Systems, Fibrecomm Networks (M) Sdn Bhd, and V Telecoms.
The plan, over the short term, is to eventually bring down the cost of Internet protocol (IP) transit by buying international bandwidth in bulk. In the longer term, the goal is to be partners of submarine cable (one which is laid beneath the sea) networks that reach US and European shores.
IP transit cost makes up about 10%-40% of total Internet cost for a player. This is what players pay to buy capacity on submarine cables to enable customers to access sites, the bulk of which are located in the United States and Europe as well in India or Australia.
IP transit is in demand, given the rising demand for broadband services. For a small player, it can be a challenge to buy capacity at a cost that allows it to make a profit.
This idea of setting up the consortium comes under the National Key Economic Area as part of the wider regional reach initiative.
“It is a positive step as a larger consortium will have more bargaining power when it negotiates for bandwidth prices,'' says an analyst from ECMLibra Investment Research in his report.
He says controlling the cost of international bandwidth was crucial as the requirement for data capacity rises exponentially, especially in the new era where data usage in smartphones and table PCs are rapidly growing.
“Over the longer term, if executed successfully, end-consumers might even enjoy lower priced Internet packages or getting more international bandwidth by paying the same price,'' he says.
Currently, TM, TDC, Maxis and Celcom are partners in various submarine-cable consortia with networks covering the United States, Europe, Middle East and Africa.
This week four individuals had been identified to be board members of KRS. Sources said they are Datuk Harold Read, Datuk Mohamed Khadar Merican, Datuk Dr Abd Samad Alias and Datuk Idris Abdullah.
“The board members must be credible as they will be the custodian of any funding that the KRS may get from the Government in the future,'' says a source.
KRS is on the lookout for a CEO and a business plan will be crafted. Capacity buying will begin in three to six months time, says another source. The bigger gainers in the consortium are most likely the smaller players as they will save costs with bulk buying.
HwangDBS Vickers Research in its note says that the lower cost of IP transit and domestic bandwidth could enhance the cellular players' overall margins but it does not expect this to impact earnings in the near term given that part of the cost savings will be passed to consumers. “TM and TDC could be on the losing end as the lower lease rates could result in lower wholesale revenues and margins, but we think the impact may not be significant to TM's bottomline given that wholesale revenues account for only 9% of total revenues. TDC generates 50% of its total revenues from wholesale business,'' it said.
Eventually, the grand plan of KRS is to have its own submarine-cable network.
For a typical 7terabits cable network with four to five fiber pairs the cost is between US$400mil and US$600mil to run from Malaysia to the United States, probably, via Hong Kong.
For that to happen, KRS needs to conduct a detailed study, says TDC chief executive officer Afzal Abdul Rahim. TDC is a member of KRS and a partner of a cable network that runs from Japan to the United States.
If it makes business sense, KRS will invest in its own cable network but securing funding would be its biggest challenge. However, it may seek a soft loan from the Government, said a source.
Afzal is looking at a two-year period, though this may be a long shot, before any cables can be dropped into the ocean.
Having KRS has its benefits but it is also to deflect any business falling to the hands of foreign cable companies that is said to have secured rights to land stations on the Malaysian shores. It is not clear whether this theory holds water but the bigger domestic players would certainly not appreciate competition on their shores if they are not allowed to land stations in other countries. “It should involve bilateral arrangement even though Malaysia has opened up access for landing stations,'' says a source.
At present, the Internet traffic mainly goes through Singapore as it cost less than via Malaysia. About 70% of Internet traffic goes ex-Singapore and while the pricing depends on volume; the average cost is said to be US$55 a month for a 1GB line and US$70 for a 200Mb line ex-Malaysia. Ex-Singapore, the cost is lower at US$50 and US$20 respectively.
Come what may, IP transit cost should come down to benefit the consumers and that can only happen if there is bulk-buying. But one thing KRS shouldn't do is to allow the bigger players like TDC or TM to restrict its freedom to buy capacity. That would, as the source said, not be in the best interest of competition.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/4/30/business/8583175
By B.K. SIDHU
bksidhu@thestar.com.my
INDEED, it is rare when two dozen telcos come together for a common goal. Instead of pulling away in different directions, a competitive industry can also compel rivals within the same industry to forge alliances.
On Monday, an agreement was inked to set up a 24-member Konsortium Rangkaian Serantau Sdn Bhd (KRS) which has a paid up capital RM240,000, thanks to the RM10,000 contribution from each member.
The telcos include Telekom Malaysia Bhd (TM), Time Dotcom Bhd (TDC), Maxis Bhd, Celcom Axiata Bhd, DiGi.Com Bhd, U Mobile Sdn Bhd, Green Packet, YTL Communications Sdn Bhd, RedTone International Bhd, OCE, Fibrerail Sdn Bhd, Jaring, Sacofa, Sarawak Information Systems, Fibrecomm Networks (M) Sdn Bhd, and V Telecoms.
The plan, over the short term, is to eventually bring down the cost of Internet protocol (IP) transit by buying international bandwidth in bulk. In the longer term, the goal is to be partners of submarine cable (one which is laid beneath the sea) networks that reach US and European shores.
IP transit cost makes up about 10%-40% of total Internet cost for a player. This is what players pay to buy capacity on submarine cables to enable customers to access sites, the bulk of which are located in the United States and Europe as well in India or Australia.
IP transit is in demand, given the rising demand for broadband services. For a small player, it can be a challenge to buy capacity at a cost that allows it to make a profit.
This idea of setting up the consortium comes under the National Key Economic Area as part of the wider regional reach initiative.
“It is a positive step as a larger consortium will have more bargaining power when it negotiates for bandwidth prices,'' says an analyst from ECMLibra Investment Research in his report.
He says controlling the cost of international bandwidth was crucial as the requirement for data capacity rises exponentially, especially in the new era where data usage in smartphones and table PCs are rapidly growing.
“Over the longer term, if executed successfully, end-consumers might even enjoy lower priced Internet packages or getting more international bandwidth by paying the same price,'' he says.
Currently, TM, TDC, Maxis and Celcom are partners in various submarine-cable consortia with networks covering the United States, Europe, Middle East and Africa.
This week four individuals had been identified to be board members of KRS. Sources said they are Datuk Harold Read, Datuk Mohamed Khadar Merican, Datuk Dr Abd Samad Alias and Datuk Idris Abdullah.
“The board members must be credible as they will be the custodian of any funding that the KRS may get from the Government in the future,'' says a source.
KRS is on the lookout for a CEO and a business plan will be crafted. Capacity buying will begin in three to six months time, says another source. The bigger gainers in the consortium are most likely the smaller players as they will save costs with bulk buying.
HwangDBS Vickers Research in its note says that the lower cost of IP transit and domestic bandwidth could enhance the cellular players' overall margins but it does not expect this to impact earnings in the near term given that part of the cost savings will be passed to consumers. “TM and TDC could be on the losing end as the lower lease rates could result in lower wholesale revenues and margins, but we think the impact may not be significant to TM's bottomline given that wholesale revenues account for only 9% of total revenues. TDC generates 50% of its total revenues from wholesale business,'' it said.
Eventually, the grand plan of KRS is to have its own submarine-cable network.
For a typical 7terabits cable network with four to five fiber pairs the cost is between US$400mil and US$600mil to run from Malaysia to the United States, probably, via Hong Kong.
For that to happen, KRS needs to conduct a detailed study, says TDC chief executive officer Afzal Abdul Rahim. TDC is a member of KRS and a partner of a cable network that runs from Japan to the United States.
If it makes business sense, KRS will invest in its own cable network but securing funding would be its biggest challenge. However, it may seek a soft loan from the Government, said a source.
Afzal is looking at a two-year period, though this may be a long shot, before any cables can be dropped into the ocean.
Having KRS has its benefits but it is also to deflect any business falling to the hands of foreign cable companies that is said to have secured rights to land stations on the Malaysian shores. It is not clear whether this theory holds water but the bigger domestic players would certainly not appreciate competition on their shores if they are not allowed to land stations in other countries. “It should involve bilateral arrangement even though Malaysia has opened up access for landing stations,'' says a source.
At present, the Internet traffic mainly goes through Singapore as it cost less than via Malaysia. About 70% of Internet traffic goes ex-Singapore and while the pricing depends on volume; the average cost is said to be US$55 a month for a 1GB line and US$70 for a 200Mb line ex-Malaysia. Ex-Singapore, the cost is lower at US$50 and US$20 respectively.
Come what may, IP transit cost should come down to benefit the consumers and that can only happen if there is bulk-buying. But one thing KRS shouldn't do is to allow the bigger players like TDC or TM to restrict its freedom to buy capacity. That would, as the source said, not be in the best interest of competition.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/4/30/business/8583175
Saturday, May 7, 2011
Pos to Defend Mail Business, Eyes E-mail Project
Friday May 6, 2011
By JEEVA ARULAMPALAM
jeeva@thestar.com.my
KUALA LUMPUR: Pos Malaysia Bhd will defend its government-related mail business as it discusses with government officials on how it can participate in the recently-proposed 1Malaysia e-mail to be implemented by Tricubes Bhd.
Should the postal services company fail to inch its way into this project, it is prepared to roll out its own e-commerce initiatives that will target government as well as commercial entities as the e-commerce pie continues to grow bigger, according to Pos Malaysia group managing director and chief executive officer Datuk Syed Faisal Albar.
“We have been working on e-commerce initiatives, such as online shopping portal posme.my, but we have also taken the cue from the Government to deepen e-government service and have worked on it as we know that it would be a significant threat to physical mail business,” he told reporters after the company's shareholders meeting yesterday.
Syed Faisal confirmed a StarBiz report last week that Pos Malaysia would see mail volumes drop further as the 1Malaysia e-mail proposal eats into the former's government-related mail portfolio.
Pos Malaysia Bhd group managing director and chief executive officer Datuk Syed Faisal Albar (right) and group chief of corporate service Datuk Jezilee Mohamad Ramli (left) speaking to reporters after the company's annual general meeting on Thursday. - Starpic by M. Rajan
“Since the project has been awarded to Tricubes, we would like to engage with both Pemandu and Mampu to understand this project and explore ways of how Pos Malaysia can play a role in this project,” he said.
“We have formulated a good plan, which includes an official inbox as we are in the delivery business, be it for digital and physical, and will table it to Pemandu and Mampu. There is no plan to charge the public but we also do not want to cannibalise our physical mail so whatever charges (imposed on the sender) will have to be reasonable to us.”
Pos Malaysia's government mail business accounted for some RM20mil in revenue from its total mail business revenue of RM624.3mil made last year.
Syed Faisal said Pos Malaysia, which has 700 post offices nationwide, was keen to develop all its land parcels, provided the amendments to the Federal Lands Commissioner Act were made. Currently, the postal services company can only carry out postal operations on these land parcels due to the Act's legislation.
“For instance, we have the general post office in KL centre built some 30-40 years ago. It is dynamic in terms of location and we can seek further value creation (by redeveloping the property). If we are allowed to re-develop, we certainly don't have the skill sets to re-develop ourselves but we would look elsewhere for the skill sets required,” he said.
Meanwhile, Pos Malaysia has not engaged with DRB-HICOM Bhd on the expected synergies that would arise from the latter emerging as a major stakeholder in Pos Malaysia or was it privy to DRB-HICOM's business proposal for the postal services company.
“All parties are observing the fact that the sale has not been consummated yet. There are certain conditions that have to be met between Khazanah (Nasional Bhd) and DRB-HICOM and some of it is beyond the control of both of them. Only when it is finalised and concluded, then we will engage with each other,” said Syed Faisal.
Government-investment arm Khazanah announced last month that it would sell its 32.21% stake in Pos Malaysia to DRB-HICOM for RM3.60 per share or RM622.8mil in total. The deal is expected to be completed by end-June and the conditional offer price of RM3.60 per share is subject to the variation in the use of 16 plots of identified lands owned by the Federal Lands Commissioner and leased to Pos Malaysia.
If the terms of the lease cannot be amended to include commercial use by year-end, then DRB-HICOM would be refunded 10 sen per share or RM17.30mil.
Analysts said a key reason for DRB-HICOM clinching Khazanah's stake in Pos Malaysia was because tie former owned Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd, and post offices could act as a financial agent and benefit the rural folk.
Currently, Pos Malaysia has already tied up with RHB Bank Bhd and Malayan Banking Bhd (Maybank) to offer financial services in selected branches.
“We will continue to respect whatever agreements we have with RHB and Maybank as we started our share banking services with them two-and-a-half years ago. If there are future plans (on Bank Muamalat), it will have to be brought to the Pos Malaysia board and decided upon,” said Syed Faisal.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/6/business/8616781&sec=business
By JEEVA ARULAMPALAM
jeeva@thestar.com.my
KUALA LUMPUR: Pos Malaysia Bhd will defend its government-related mail business as it discusses with government officials on how it can participate in the recently-proposed 1Malaysia e-mail to be implemented by Tricubes Bhd.
Should the postal services company fail to inch its way into this project, it is prepared to roll out its own e-commerce initiatives that will target government as well as commercial entities as the e-commerce pie continues to grow bigger, according to Pos Malaysia group managing director and chief executive officer Datuk Syed Faisal Albar.
“We have been working on e-commerce initiatives, such as online shopping portal posme.my, but we have also taken the cue from the Government to deepen e-government service and have worked on it as we know that it would be a significant threat to physical mail business,” he told reporters after the company's shareholders meeting yesterday.
Syed Faisal confirmed a StarBiz report last week that Pos Malaysia would see mail volumes drop further as the 1Malaysia e-mail proposal eats into the former's government-related mail portfolio.
Pos Malaysia Bhd group managing director and chief executive officer Datuk Syed Faisal Albar (right) and group chief of corporate service Datuk Jezilee Mohamad Ramli (left) speaking to reporters after the company's annual general meeting on Thursday. - Starpic by M. Rajan
“Since the project has been awarded to Tricubes, we would like to engage with both Pemandu and Mampu to understand this project and explore ways of how Pos Malaysia can play a role in this project,” he said.
“We have formulated a good plan, which includes an official inbox as we are in the delivery business, be it for digital and physical, and will table it to Pemandu and Mampu. There is no plan to charge the public but we also do not want to cannibalise our physical mail so whatever charges (imposed on the sender) will have to be reasonable to us.”
Pos Malaysia's government mail business accounted for some RM20mil in revenue from its total mail business revenue of RM624.3mil made last year.
Syed Faisal said Pos Malaysia, which has 700 post offices nationwide, was keen to develop all its land parcels, provided the amendments to the Federal Lands Commissioner Act were made. Currently, the postal services company can only carry out postal operations on these land parcels due to the Act's legislation.
“For instance, we have the general post office in KL centre built some 30-40 years ago. It is dynamic in terms of location and we can seek further value creation (by redeveloping the property). If we are allowed to re-develop, we certainly don't have the skill sets to re-develop ourselves but we would look elsewhere for the skill sets required,” he said.
Meanwhile, Pos Malaysia has not engaged with DRB-HICOM Bhd on the expected synergies that would arise from the latter emerging as a major stakeholder in Pos Malaysia or was it privy to DRB-HICOM's business proposal for the postal services company.
“All parties are observing the fact that the sale has not been consummated yet. There are certain conditions that have to be met between Khazanah (Nasional Bhd) and DRB-HICOM and some of it is beyond the control of both of them. Only when it is finalised and concluded, then we will engage with each other,” said Syed Faisal.
Government-investment arm Khazanah announced last month that it would sell its 32.21% stake in Pos Malaysia to DRB-HICOM for RM3.60 per share or RM622.8mil in total. The deal is expected to be completed by end-June and the conditional offer price of RM3.60 per share is subject to the variation in the use of 16 plots of identified lands owned by the Federal Lands Commissioner and leased to Pos Malaysia.
If the terms of the lease cannot be amended to include commercial use by year-end, then DRB-HICOM would be refunded 10 sen per share or RM17.30mil.
Analysts said a key reason for DRB-HICOM clinching Khazanah's stake in Pos Malaysia was because tie former owned Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd, and post offices could act as a financial agent and benefit the rural folk.
Currently, Pos Malaysia has already tied up with RHB Bank Bhd and Malayan Banking Bhd (Maybank) to offer financial services in selected branches.
“We will continue to respect whatever agreements we have with RHB and Maybank as we started our share banking services with them two-and-a-half years ago. If there are future plans (on Bank Muamalat), it will have to be brought to the Pos Malaysia board and decided upon,” said Syed Faisal.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/5/6/business/8616781&sec=business
Saturday, April 23, 2011
Khazanah Sells Pos Malaysia stake to DRB-HICOM
Saturday April 23, 2011
By SHARIDAN M. ALI
sharidan@thestar.com.my
KUALA LUMPUR: Government investment arm, Khazanah Nasional Bhd will divest its strategic stake of 32.21% in Pos Malaysia Bhd to DRB-Hicom Bhd at RM3.60 per share or RM622.79mil.
The transaction is deemed as a landmark divestment as it is Khazanah's first divestment of its entire stake in a major government-linked company (GLC).
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/4/23/business/8541352&sec=business
The decision was made after an extensive two-stage process as well as rigorous selection to ensure that the new shareholder was able to bring Pos to the next level of growth.
Khazanah managing director, Tan Sri Azman Mokhtar said DRB-HICOM was chosen based on their overall bid, which offered not only a defined strategy but also an executable business plan and an acceptable offer price.
Stage one of the divestment process saw the resolution relating to the salary of postmen and the revision of postal tariffs.
“Their proposed strategy and business plan in turn provides an effective platform for Pos' growth, if adopted by the board of Pos as a whole,” he said in a statement yesterday.
The offer price of RM3.60 per share is subject to the modification of the special rights redeemable preference share in Pos (special share) held by Minister of Finance Inc. (MoF).
This modification inter alia includes the reservation to appoint up to two board members in Pos; and the removal of rights to appoint the chairman and managing director of Pos and fix their respective remunerations.
This condition precedent is not within Khazanah's control, as it is the sole prerogative of MoF to make any modification on the special share.
The conditional offer price is also subject to the variation in the use of 16 plots of identified lands owned by the Federal Lands Commissioner and leased to Pos. The current terms of the lease only allows for postal services use, while the variation provides for the inclusion of commercial use, over and above the mandatory postal use. In the event the variation does not happen by Dec 31, DRB-HICOM will be refunded 10 sen per share or RM17.30mil.
Khazanah adopted a robust strategic divestment process which involved an open bidding process and a merit-based and transparent selection process. Conducted in two stages the first stage involved addressing key aspects of Pos' macro business and regulatory environments, while the second stage revolved around the restricted tender process.
Stage one saw the resolution of the long-running issue relating to the salary of postmen and the revision of postal tariffs. The postal rate revision took effect in July 1, last year and subsequently, Pos also resolved a long outstanding pay revision for postmen in the same month.
Stage two started with the pre-qualification phase, where Khazanah appointed CIMB Investment Bank Bhd and McKinsey & Company as advisors for the transaction. A total of 48 parties were approached to submit their respective proposals, of which 10 parties expressed their interest to participate and were pre-qualified.
Khazanah then proceeded to the indicative bid phase where all 10 parties were invited to submit their bids. Of these, five reverted with their respective bids where they were all given detailed and equal opportunities to meet Khazanah's advisors and explain their respective strategy and business plan submission.
Of the five bidders, four parties submitted their binding bids.
An independent evaluation panel comprising five senior professionals from the public and private sector with extensive postal and corporate experience had evaluated all the bidders' proposal on the basis of anonymity, where the bidders' names were coded.
The panel, with the assistance of Khazanah's advisors, evaluated the strategy and business plans first. Based on this, the bidders were shortlisted to a final two. Subsequently, the offer price envelopes were opened and evaluated compositely. Both shortlisted bidders were given the opportunity to present to the panel. The panel's evaluation was based on a composite score between strategy and pricing, whereby strategy accounted for 60% and pricing 40%. Based on the composite score, the panel unanimously recommended DRB-HICOM.
Azman said there was a fit and proper test of the new majority shareholder which includes promoting the sustainable development of the universal service obligations (USO), as well as the commitment to retain existing staff in their business plan.
“The commitment to fulfil the social obligations under the USO (as required under the Postal Services Act, 1991) is crucial as postal services have an impact on the rakyat, especially for those residing in remote or rural areas,” he said.
Khazanah's emphasis on strategy and business plans within the evaluation process does not in itself make any assumption of control or otherwise. The process required bidders having to state, in their own opinion, whether a general offer (GO) would be necessary or not.
Khazanah's executive director of investments, who was the project director for this strategic divestment, Mohammed Rashdan Mohd Yusof said it was the buyer's prerogative, and not of the seller, to determine whether a GO was necessary, as only the buyer can ascertain the extent of control they exert over Pos after they acquired the 32% stake.
“Furthermore, the divestment process did not reveal any information to the bidders beyond readily available market information” he said.
Azman concluded: “As a responsible seller to stakeholders including minorities and the rakyat, our emphasis was to ensure that the successful bidder had a robust business plan to both deliver their USO and unlock value and for them to discuss at the Pos board.
The divestment of Khazanah stake in POS was first announced in March 2010 by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak at Invest Malaysia 2010 conference.
Since then, many prominent names were speculated to be the buyer of the stake. It was reported that besides DRB-HICOM, Nationwide Express Courier Services Bhd and Scomi Group Bhd were among the shortlisted bidders.
Related Story:
By SHARIDAN M. ALI
sharidan@thestar.com.my
KUALA LUMPUR: Government investment arm, Khazanah Nasional Bhd will divest its strategic stake of 32.21% in Pos Malaysia Bhd to DRB-Hicom Bhd at RM3.60 per share or RM622.79mil.
The transaction is deemed as a landmark divestment as it is Khazanah's first divestment of its entire stake in a major government-linked company (GLC).
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/4/23/business/8541352&sec=business
The decision was made after an extensive two-stage process as well as rigorous selection to ensure that the new shareholder was able to bring Pos to the next level of growth.
Khazanah managing director, Tan Sri Azman Mokhtar said DRB-HICOM was chosen based on their overall bid, which offered not only a defined strategy but also an executable business plan and an acceptable offer price.
Stage one of the divestment process saw the resolution relating to the salary of postmen and the revision of postal tariffs.
“Their proposed strategy and business plan in turn provides an effective platform for Pos' growth, if adopted by the board of Pos as a whole,” he said in a statement yesterday.
The offer price of RM3.60 per share is subject to the modification of the special rights redeemable preference share in Pos (special share) held by Minister of Finance Inc. (MoF).
This modification inter alia includes the reservation to appoint up to two board members in Pos; and the removal of rights to appoint the chairman and managing director of Pos and fix their respective remunerations.
This condition precedent is not within Khazanah's control, as it is the sole prerogative of MoF to make any modification on the special share.
The conditional offer price is also subject to the variation in the use of 16 plots of identified lands owned by the Federal Lands Commissioner and leased to Pos. The current terms of the lease only allows for postal services use, while the variation provides for the inclusion of commercial use, over and above the mandatory postal use. In the event the variation does not happen by Dec 31, DRB-HICOM will be refunded 10 sen per share or RM17.30mil.
Khazanah adopted a robust strategic divestment process which involved an open bidding process and a merit-based and transparent selection process. Conducted in two stages the first stage involved addressing key aspects of Pos' macro business and regulatory environments, while the second stage revolved around the restricted tender process.
Stage one saw the resolution of the long-running issue relating to the salary of postmen and the revision of postal tariffs. The postal rate revision took effect in July 1, last year and subsequently, Pos also resolved a long outstanding pay revision for postmen in the same month.
Stage two started with the pre-qualification phase, where Khazanah appointed CIMB Investment Bank Bhd and McKinsey & Company as advisors for the transaction. A total of 48 parties were approached to submit their respective proposals, of which 10 parties expressed their interest to participate and were pre-qualified.
Khazanah then proceeded to the indicative bid phase where all 10 parties were invited to submit their bids. Of these, five reverted with their respective bids where they were all given detailed and equal opportunities to meet Khazanah's advisors and explain their respective strategy and business plan submission.
Of the five bidders, four parties submitted their binding bids.
An independent evaluation panel comprising five senior professionals from the public and private sector with extensive postal and corporate experience had evaluated all the bidders' proposal on the basis of anonymity, where the bidders' names were coded.
The panel, with the assistance of Khazanah's advisors, evaluated the strategy and business plans first. Based on this, the bidders were shortlisted to a final two. Subsequently, the offer price envelopes were opened and evaluated compositely. Both shortlisted bidders were given the opportunity to present to the panel. The panel's evaluation was based on a composite score between strategy and pricing, whereby strategy accounted for 60% and pricing 40%. Based on the composite score, the panel unanimously recommended DRB-HICOM.
Azman said there was a fit and proper test of the new majority shareholder which includes promoting the sustainable development of the universal service obligations (USO), as well as the commitment to retain existing staff in their business plan.
“The commitment to fulfil the social obligations under the USO (as required under the Postal Services Act, 1991) is crucial as postal services have an impact on the rakyat, especially for those residing in remote or rural areas,” he said.
Khazanah's emphasis on strategy and business plans within the evaluation process does not in itself make any assumption of control or otherwise. The process required bidders having to state, in their own opinion, whether a general offer (GO) would be necessary or not.
Khazanah's executive director of investments, who was the project director for this strategic divestment, Mohammed Rashdan Mohd Yusof said it was the buyer's prerogative, and not of the seller, to determine whether a GO was necessary, as only the buyer can ascertain the extent of control they exert over Pos after they acquired the 32% stake.
“Furthermore, the divestment process did not reveal any information to the bidders beyond readily available market information” he said.
Azman concluded: “As a responsible seller to stakeholders including minorities and the rakyat, our emphasis was to ensure that the successful bidder had a robust business plan to both deliver their USO and unlock value and for them to discuss at the Pos board.
The divestment of Khazanah stake in POS was first announced in March 2010 by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak at Invest Malaysia 2010 conference.
Since then, many prominent names were speculated to be the buyer of the stake. It was reported that besides DRB-HICOM, Nationwide Express Courier Services Bhd and Scomi Group Bhd were among the shortlisted bidders.
Related Story:
Friday, April 22, 2011
Are You Getting a Rude Shock With Hidden Charges When You Get Telephone Bills?
Friday April 22, 2011
Friday Reflections - By B.K. Sidhu
Don't hide, be transparent in charges and rates.
No one likes a rude shock in the form of a big bill after a holiday, certainly not for making voice calls or just for some music downloads.
But that is the global reality. Blame it on the “blacks, iPhones, Galaxy and tablets.''
These are irresistible devices; they provide flexibility and keep you connected. They can also rack up big bills without you knowing it because they access the Internet to carry out automatic updates.
Some don't even allow data roaming but many have been surprised with weird charges' creeping into the bills, no matter how careful they are. Of course, all these nasty big bills can be avoided if there is greater transparency in plans, charges, bills and caps, similar to what is practised in Europe.
Data is the story of today but if you look back over a decade ago, voice roaming was the story and it was a very expensive affair to roam and talk. Frequent travellers have a lot of stories to tell of their nasty' roaming bills. It is not that it has stopped but people have found alternatives in IDD cards, buying SIMs from the country they travel to and even skype or chat on the many social platforms that are available.
There has been a call to reduce roaming rates for a long time. In 2007, the government did ask the celcos to reduce the rates but then, the celcos were not ready to stomach a reduction.
Then, voice was king and no matter how small the roaming revenue contribution was, it was still a contribution.
But things have changed and they are more willing to reduce rates, more so since voice revenues are going downhill.
So effective May 1, the voice and SMS roaming rates between Malaysia and Singapore will be slashed by 20% and 30% respectively. Call it a landmark pack to curb sky-high usage charges, but it could not have been achieved without the intervention of the ministries and regulators from both the countries.
Going by the original plan, the rates should be reduced by 30% and 50% but it will be done in stages. This May, it is 20% and 30% and next May, it will be adjusted to 30% for voice and 50% for SMS within both countries. It is only applicable for two years; after that, rates can go north, south or remain status quo.
This will be a test case before we can see any more reduction in roaming. And the whole of Asean will watch how this deal fares. If it works, they may want to replicate it. Hopefully, we will have a single rate across Asean one day - the way Europe has one rate for voice roaming.
The impact of the reduction is not going to be huge on the celcos in the two countries since voice revenues are going down. For now, roaming revenues make up about 10%-25% of Singapore telcos' mobile revenue versus 8%-10% for Malaysian telcos, says an analyst in his report.
He adds that “a reciprocal 20% reduction in roaming tariffs between the two countries (assuming a third of telcos' roaming revenue is derived from inbound/outbound roamers in both countries) would slice Singapore mobile revenue by 1%-2% compared with an estimated 0.5%-0.9% for Malaysian celcos, all else being equal.''
But if you ask the celcos, they may paint a “pitiful story'' of how much they will lose.
Perhaps, they should think of more creative ways to monetise their dumb pipes and with data growing the way it is, the loss in voice roaming can be easily compensated by data growth. Operators can also share and swap minutes with one another.
So, it is a great effort but the fear of users is that the celcos may reduce one sector and increase another to compensate for the shortfall. To avoid that, there should be a transparent pricing formula and rates.
Or else you cannot avoid a situation where users say “if there is no transparency, we will not be surprised if we end up paying the same amount even after May 1.”
It will become the story of “unlimited data usage,'' but in reality, there is a limit and if you surpass that, the charges roll in. So do you wonder where the unlimited factor is?
Deputy news editor B.K. Sidhu feels that there should be a massive revamp of data charges to bring down the entry level cost so that more Malaysians can be part of the “connected net world.''
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/4/22/business/8535371&sec=business
Friday Reflections - By B.K. Sidhu
Don't hide, be transparent in charges and rates.
No one likes a rude shock in the form of a big bill after a holiday, certainly not for making voice calls or just for some music downloads.
But that is the global reality. Blame it on the “blacks, iPhones, Galaxy and tablets.''
These are irresistible devices; they provide flexibility and keep you connected. They can also rack up big bills without you knowing it because they access the Internet to carry out automatic updates.
Some don't even allow data roaming but many have been surprised with weird charges' creeping into the bills, no matter how careful they are. Of course, all these nasty big bills can be avoided if there is greater transparency in plans, charges, bills and caps, similar to what is practised in Europe.
Data is the story of today but if you look back over a decade ago, voice roaming was the story and it was a very expensive affair to roam and talk. Frequent travellers have a lot of stories to tell of their nasty' roaming bills. It is not that it has stopped but people have found alternatives in IDD cards, buying SIMs from the country they travel to and even skype or chat on the many social platforms that are available.
There has been a call to reduce roaming rates for a long time. In 2007, the government did ask the celcos to reduce the rates but then, the celcos were not ready to stomach a reduction.
Then, voice was king and no matter how small the roaming revenue contribution was, it was still a contribution.
But things have changed and they are more willing to reduce rates, more so since voice revenues are going downhill.
So effective May 1, the voice and SMS roaming rates between Malaysia and Singapore will be slashed by 20% and 30% respectively. Call it a landmark pack to curb sky-high usage charges, but it could not have been achieved without the intervention of the ministries and regulators from both the countries.
Going by the original plan, the rates should be reduced by 30% and 50% but it will be done in stages. This May, it is 20% and 30% and next May, it will be adjusted to 30% for voice and 50% for SMS within both countries. It is only applicable for two years; after that, rates can go north, south or remain status quo.
This will be a test case before we can see any more reduction in roaming. And the whole of Asean will watch how this deal fares. If it works, they may want to replicate it. Hopefully, we will have a single rate across Asean one day - the way Europe has one rate for voice roaming.
The impact of the reduction is not going to be huge on the celcos in the two countries since voice revenues are going down. For now, roaming revenues make up about 10%-25% of Singapore telcos' mobile revenue versus 8%-10% for Malaysian telcos, says an analyst in his report.
He adds that “a reciprocal 20% reduction in roaming tariffs between the two countries (assuming a third of telcos' roaming revenue is derived from inbound/outbound roamers in both countries) would slice Singapore mobile revenue by 1%-2% compared with an estimated 0.5%-0.9% for Malaysian celcos, all else being equal.''
But if you ask the celcos, they may paint a “pitiful story'' of how much they will lose.
Perhaps, they should think of more creative ways to monetise their dumb pipes and with data growing the way it is, the loss in voice roaming can be easily compensated by data growth. Operators can also share and swap minutes with one another.
So, it is a great effort but the fear of users is that the celcos may reduce one sector and increase another to compensate for the shortfall. To avoid that, there should be a transparent pricing formula and rates.
Or else you cannot avoid a situation where users say “if there is no transparency, we will not be surprised if we end up paying the same amount even after May 1.”
It will become the story of “unlimited data usage,'' but in reality, there is a limit and if you surpass that, the charges roll in. So do you wonder where the unlimited factor is?
Deputy news editor B.K. Sidhu feels that there should be a massive revamp of data charges to bring down the entry level cost so that more Malaysians can be part of the “connected net world.''
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/4/22/business/8535371&sec=business
Saturday, April 16, 2011
Mobile Broadband Gains Popularity
Thursday April 14, 2011
BY DALJIT DHESI
daljit@thestar.com.my
PETALING JAYA: Mobile broadband in Malaysia is fast gaining popularity among Internet users and has overtaken fixed broadband in market share.
Market share of for this channel of Internet connection had more than doubled to 54% last year compared with 20% in 2009, according to the Nielsen Mobile Insights Survey 2010.
“Fixed broadband, however, decreased by 23 points to 42%. Dial-up is close to obsolete with only 2% of subscriptions,” The Nielsen Company director of customised research client services Luca Griseri said at a press briefing on the findings of the survey.
The Nielsen Mobile Insights Survey was conducted between October and December 2010. Almost 4,000 consumers across the nation were polled about their usage of mobile phones and the Internet.
As the mobile broadband gains more market share, Griseri added, it was not surprising that laptops and netbooks were the devices most frequently used to access the Internet (55%).
Accessing the Internet on mobile phones has increased significantly to 11% (up nine points compared to 2009).
As for large screen access to the Internet, uploading on social networking is the most common activity across all age groups.
Almost half of the respondents aged 20-34 own a 3G phone.
“Over the last year, advanced phones have become more available and more affordable, with many new models and many more data plan options being launched. This is important because, as our data show (and as observed in most countries in South-East Asia), increased ownership of advanced phones does gradually change users' behaviours.
“For example, smartphone owners are more likely to access the Internet on their mobile phones, and in general use more data,” he noted.
But Griseri said there were still almost half of the respondents (at 48%) in the age group of 20-34 years who had not been using the 3G functions even though they owned a 3G phone, as cost was the main barrier.
For this year, he said he expected it to be another exciting and dynamic year for mobile phone and Internet usage in the country.
“The main trends started last year, such as the uptake of smartphones, and the increasing usage of data will continue. At the same time, new trends, for example the success of tablet computers, will further change the market and affect consumers' expectations,” he added.
Internet usage stood at 41% last year compared with 25% a year ago, he said, adding that the highest usage was among the youth group aged 20 to 24 years old.
Griseri said with the rapid changes in the Internet and mobile broadband space, telecommunications players, besides offering the latest products and services, should also focus on the customer experience, i.e. delivering what really matters to users, with a strong emphasis on the quality of service.
“Even more than in the past, flexibility and simplicity will be key success factors: allowing users to do what they want, where and when they want to, and avoiding confusing them, by ensuring that simplicity really permeates all aspects of the propositions offered, from product to service and price,” he added.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/4/14/business/20110414110328&sec=business
BY DALJIT DHESI
daljit@thestar.com.my
PETALING JAYA: Mobile broadband in Malaysia is fast gaining popularity among Internet users and has overtaken fixed broadband in market share.
Market share of for this channel of Internet connection had more than doubled to 54% last year compared with 20% in 2009, according to the Nielsen Mobile Insights Survey 2010.
“Fixed broadband, however, decreased by 23 points to 42%. Dial-up is close to obsolete with only 2% of subscriptions,” The Nielsen Company director of customised research client services Luca Griseri said at a press briefing on the findings of the survey.
The Nielsen Mobile Insights Survey was conducted between October and December 2010. Almost 4,000 consumers across the nation were polled about their usage of mobile phones and the Internet.
As the mobile broadband gains more market share, Griseri added, it was not surprising that laptops and netbooks were the devices most frequently used to access the Internet (55%).
Accessing the Internet on mobile phones has increased significantly to 11% (up nine points compared to 2009).
As for large screen access to the Internet, uploading on social networking is the most common activity across all age groups.
Almost half of the respondents aged 20-34 own a 3G phone.
“Over the last year, advanced phones have become more available and more affordable, with many new models and many more data plan options being launched. This is important because, as our data show (and as observed in most countries in South-East Asia), increased ownership of advanced phones does gradually change users' behaviours.
“For example, smartphone owners are more likely to access the Internet on their mobile phones, and in general use more data,” he noted.
But Griseri said there were still almost half of the respondents (at 48%) in the age group of 20-34 years who had not been using the 3G functions even though they owned a 3G phone, as cost was the main barrier.
For this year, he said he expected it to be another exciting and dynamic year for mobile phone and Internet usage in the country.
“The main trends started last year, such as the uptake of smartphones, and the increasing usage of data will continue. At the same time, new trends, for example the success of tablet computers, will further change the market and affect consumers' expectations,” he added.
Internet usage stood at 41% last year compared with 25% a year ago, he said, adding that the highest usage was among the youth group aged 20 to 24 years old.
Griseri said with the rapid changes in the Internet and mobile broadband space, telecommunications players, besides offering the latest products and services, should also focus on the customer experience, i.e. delivering what really matters to users, with a strong emphasis on the quality of service.
“Even more than in the past, flexibility and simplicity will be key success factors: allowing users to do what they want, where and when they want to, and avoiding confusing them, by ensuring that simplicity really permeates all aspects of the propositions offered, from product to service and price,” he added.
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/4/14/business/20110414110328&sec=business
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)